Bringing dramatic and game-changing increases in capability and computing, QITs are poised to raise significant questions about the future of financial services in the areas of security, competition and policy. An FCA workshop heard the views and proposals from experts in both technology and finance.
What is QIT?
Quantum Information Technology (QIT) refers to the broad fields of quantum computing and quantum communications that are developing computer technology based on principles of quantum mechanics (which explains the properties of nature on the atomic and subatomic levels) and quantum information science. Classical computers of today use ‘bits’ to encode information in the values of 0 or 1, while quantum computers use ‘qubits’ (quantum bits).
See: Quantum Computers Challenge Blockchain’s Invincibility: What To Do Now
These qubits rely on exceptional abilities of subatomic particles to be in two (or more) states at the same time – a phenomenon called quantum superposition. In computing terms, they can be both 0 and 1 at the same time, thus enabling a wide range of computing capability and potential when connected with other qubits through quantum entanglement.
Security & Encryption within QIT
QIT poses a potential existential threat to the many encryption methods used today. Although these risks are not yet crystallised and the timelines are uncertain, attendees of the workshop agreed that QIT poses a threat to the integrity and stability of financial services. They also agreed that there was a fundamental lack of education and awareness of the quantum encryption risk for financial services. The National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) has previously warned that organisations should already be considering how to protect their data from quantum-powered threats. Despite this, attendees agreed that the industry is not as proactive or engaged on this topic as it should be.
QIT Potential Impact on Competition in FS
It is widely expected that most QIT users, including in financial services, will access resources over cloud-style shared quantum servers, rather than owning their own quantum computing resources. This “democratisation” of access could remove some barriers to competition and barriers to entry and reduce competitive advantage. However, the counterargument is that smaller firms might not have the necessary foundational capability and talent to work with these emerging technologies leading to a two-tier market.
See: Gangster capitalism and the American theft of Chinese innovation
At the same time, such ‘democratised’ access is usually provided by ‘BigTech’ firms such as Amazon Quantum Solutions and Google Quantum AI. Combined with these global giants’ increasing role in financial services (such as Amazon Lending and Google Pay) and high dependency of the sector on cloud services could lead to market concentration, with a small number of firms dominating the provision of services.
Policy Considerations of QIT and Emerging Technologies
From the lack of explainability of quantum algorithms to the uncertainty of third-party data processing through Quantum-as-a-Service (as banks will have to use external systems to process data), there are important questions about how policy and regulation should react to QIT in financial services, including whether regulators will be able to remain technologically-neutral in their response.
On the policy side, there is an extensive discussion on the ‘explainability’ of AI across international regulatory jurisdictions. QIT could raise very similar questions due to the complex nature of quantum processes. On the one hand this is a new challenge, while at the same time the workshop discussion suggested lessons learned and solutions developed could be shared between the two fields.
Leave a Reply