Binance Left Canada but the Fight Reached Supreme Court

October 28, 2026 | NCFA Story Intelligence | Regulation And Policy, Digital Assets Blockchain And Tokenization, Competition And Market Structure, Capital Markets Infrastructure And Funding

AI illustration of Binance Canada exit and Supreme Court fight over OSC regulatory powers, document demands and crypto market access

How Binance’s Canadian Exit Became a Supreme Court Fight Over Regulatory Reach

Binance thought it was leaving Canada in 2023. The regulatory fight stayed behind.

Binance never entered Canada the way a bank or securities dealer would. It didn’t open a Canadian branch, build a local exchange or wait for a Canadian licence. Changpeng Zhao was a Canadian entrepreneur who had studied computer science at McGill, but Binance launched in Shanghai in July 2017 and grew into the world’s largest crypto exchange by trading volume within about six months. The product was global from the start. Borders came later.

By 2021, Canadian regulators were catching up with what that model meant on the ground. Ontario pushed Binance out. Binance hired former regulators, incorporated in Alberta and tried to build its way back in. Then Canada tightened the rules again. On May 2, 2023, Binance told securities regulators it planned to withdraw nationally.

Eight days later, the OSC opened an investigation. The next day came a sweeping demand for company records. On May 12, Binance told the public it was leaving Canada.

The exit and the investigation crossed in real time. Binance was trying to close one Canadian chapter while the regulator was opening another.

Three years later, that unfinished business has reached the Supreme Court of Canada. Ontario’s Court of Appeal has already ruled that part of the OSC summons went too far. The OSC wants that ruling overturned. Nine interveners now include civil liberties groups, securities regulators and four governments.

What follows is a story of a borderless crypto company meeting national regulators, leaving some markets, adapting in others, and discovering that a market exit doesn’t make the regulatory past disappear.

Ontario Puts a Border Around a Borderless Exchange 2021

Binance enters 2021 with the advantages that made it enormous. It is fast, broad and easy to reach across borders. Regulators see the same features and start asking who is accountable when local investors use the platform. Binance: The low-down on the drama-ridden crypto exchange was already tracking warnings and restrictions from the UK, Japan, Malaysia, Thailand and other markets that summer. Ontario joins the push.

In March, securities regulators tell crypto platforms serving the province to start the registration process or face enforcement. Binance doesn’t register. On June 25, it makes Ontario a restricted jurisdiction and tells users to close their active positions by year end.1
Binance’s scale has created leverage. It has also created a supervision problem for regulators.

Ontario treats access as local activity. The OSC’s position is that platforms offering securities or derivatives to Ontario users can’t avoid provincial rules simply because the company or servers sit somewhere else. For internet based finance, the customer’s location can pull a global platform into a local regulatory system.

Binance starts planning a return. By early 2022, Binance is doing something that would have looked unlikely months earlier. It hires former Canadian regulators, incorporates in Alberta and starts building toward full registration. Binance hires ex-regulators and incorporates in Alberta to charter compliance course in Canada catches the pivot. A few months later, Alberta-based Binance Canada expects to return to Ontario by 2024 shows how far the strategy has moved. The company isn’t talking about abandoning Canada. It is talking about coming back to Ontario through the front door.

Ontario Is Supposed to Be Closed but Trading Continues 2021 to 2022

The attempted reset quickly runs into the controls Binance says are already in place.

On December 29, 2021, Binance tells Ontario users it can continue operating in the province. The OSC publicly says it can’t. Binance later acknowledges that its message was wrong. The company also tells the OSC that Ontario trading restrictions are in place while some Ontario users can still trade.

By March 2022, the disagreement is no longer informal. Binance signs a legally enforceable undertaking, agrees to block new Ontario accounts, wind down restricted products, strengthen controls and report back to the regulator.2
Binance is trying to prove it can be regulated in Canada while the OSC is testing whether its existing controls actually work.

What Binance Agreed to in Ontario

The undertaking records the sequence in Binance’s own words. It says the company announced its Ontario withdrawal in June 2021, incorrectly told users in December that operations could continue, and later confirmed that some Ontario investors had continued trading after restrictions were supposed to be in place.

Binance committed to prevent new Ontario accounts, identify existing accounts, block trading except for permitted transactions, wind down leveraged and other restricted products, waive or reimburse certain withdrawal fees, train relevant staff and retain an independent third party to assess whether its controls worked.

The document doesn’t say Binance can never return. It says the controls stay in place unless OSC staff provide written confirmation that they can be removed.

Binance agrees to end operations in Ontario; OSC Publishes Binance’s Undertaking Statement shows why the 2022 agreement was more than another exchange announcement. Binance had moved from a voluntary market exit to enforceable commitments about who could use the platform and what the company had to prove to the regulator.

The OSC gets enforceable controls. The undertaking turns account restrictions, product wind downs and monitoring into commitments the regulator can supervise. Binance is no longer only deciding what Ontario access should look like on its own.

Binance still sees a Canadian future. The company pursues registration outside Ontario and talks publicly about returning. That makes the national exit in 2023 more than a market withdrawal. It ends an attempted compliance strategy.

Regulators Around the World Start Closing the Gaps 2021 to 2023

Canada is only one front in a much larger regulatory push. By 2023, Binance has spent years building for a global crypto market while regulators keep answering with national licences, local entities and customer protections. Britain restricts Binance Markets Limited. The Netherlands fines the company for operating without registration. Japan warns it about serving residents without registration. Australia examines how it classifies derivatives customers.

The pressure isn’t only legal. Banking relationships, product access, executive attention and market share all start carrying a regulatory price. Will Binance Severes U.S. Ties in Face of Crypto Crackdown captures the mood in February 2023, when Binance is already reconsidering parts of its US exposure.

Binance can keep operating globally, but it can’t keep operating everywhere in the same way.

Why Binance Left Some Markets and Adapted in Others
Britain draws a supervisory line. In 2021, the Financial Conduct Authority restricts Binance Markets Limited and says the firm isn’t permitted to undertake regulated activity without consent. The episode becomes part of a broader regulatory push over whether authorities can identify the legal entity, obtain information and supervise the business effectively.3
Japan becomes an adaptation story. Japan’s Financial Services Agency had warned Binance about unregistered activity. Binance later acquires locally registered Sakura Exchange BitCoin and launches Binance Japan in August 2023. The global platform is then withdrawn for Japanese residents as customers migrate to the local entity. The current FSA register still lists Binance Japan as a registered crypto exchange operator.4
Belgium pushes Binance toward an EEA entity. In June 2023, the FSMA orders Binance to stop certain exchange and custody services being supplied from non EEA entities. Two months later, the regulator says Belgian clients can choose to work with Binance Poland, subject to individual consent.5
Australia keeps looking after the product changes. Binance Australia Derivatives asks to cancel its licence in April 2023 while ASIC is reviewing client classification. In 2026, a Federal Court orders a A$10 million penalty after Binance admits that 524 retail investors were misclassified and exposed to high risk derivatives without required protections.6A single global operating model keeps giving way to local entities, local permissions, product restrictions or market exits. Binance leaves some markets and rebuilds inside the rules of others.

Binance Decides Canada Isn’t Worth the New Rules May 2023

For a while, Binance looks prepared to absorb the cost of becoming a regulated Canadian business. In 2023, that calculation flips.

New Canadian requirements tighten expectations around custody, leverage, stablecoins and investor limits. Those rules don’t make crypto trading impossible. Other platforms stay. But they narrow the product Binance can offer and increase what it has to build around compliance.

On May 2, Binance tells the Alberta Securities Commission, acting for the CSA, that it plans to withdraw. Ten days later, it tells the public that Canada’s rules around stablecoins and investor limits have made the market “no longer tenable.”7
Binance Withdraws from Canadian Market due to Tightened Crypto Regulations records the exit. Dispelling FUD: Why Binance’s Exit from Canadian Crypto Markets Strengthens Canada’s Ecosystem captured the opposing industry view that stricter Canadian rules could strengthen the market rather than weaken it.

Canada can tighten investor protections and still make the market less attractive to some global firms. Binance decides the trade no longer works for its business.

Binance blames the rule set, not Canada itself. The company says it delayed the decision while looking for another route and hopes to return someday. Canada is a relatively small market for Binance, but the evidence doesn’t establish that size alone drove the exit. The company’s own explanation focused on the rule set and the product limits that came with it.

Other platforms make a different calculation. Some exchanges also leave, while others pursue Canadian registration and accept narrower product menus. Every platform has to decide whether the local opportunity justifies the controls, product limits and ongoing supervision required to stay.

Leaving Canada Doesn’t End the Investigation 2023 to 2025

On May 10, only eight days after Binance privately tells regulators it intends to leave, the OSC opens an investigation. On May 11, an investigator issues the summons. On May 12, Binance announces its Canadian exit to the public.

The exchange is trying to leave the market. The regulator is trying to reconstruct what happened before the door closes.

Within weeks, OSC Pursues Binance Investigation, Unfazed by Crypto Exchange’s Departure from Canada is already documenting the next fight. Binance argues that the OSC is reopening conduct covered by the 2022 undertaking. The OSC maintains it still has investigative authority.

Leaving Canada changes Binance’s future business. It doesn’t settle its Canadian past.

What the OSC Actually Demanded

The OSC investigation order identifies allegations involving unregistered trading, distributions without a prospectus, possible steps to circumvent Ontario securities law and compliance controls, and allegedly misleading statements to the regulator. Binance disputes aspects of the OSC’s case, and those allegations aren’t findings of wrongdoing in the Supreme Court proceeding.

The summons then goes much wider than a narrow request for documents tied to one transaction. It demands, for the period beginning January 1, 2021, “all communications regarding Ontario (or Canada generally)” among directors, officers, employees, contractors, agents and consultants of Binance and related entities.8

That wording is what ultimately troubles the Ontario Court of Appeal. A regulator can compel business records. A regulated firm also has a lower expectation of privacy than an ordinary person in many contexts. But the Court says even a low privacy expectation doesn’t permit a demand without a reasonable foundation to believe the records may be relevant.

The Court later describes the request as “staggering in its breadth” because it could capture communications across virtually anyone working for Binance or related entities, across all of Canada, without limiting every category to the subjects under investigation.

The OSC remains free to investigate and issue another summons that complies with the Charter. The dispute is about how broad the compulsory demand can be, not whether Binance is beyond investigation.

Canada’s Other Binance Overhang

The OSC case isn’t the only Canadian issue that survives Binance’s exit. FINTRAC later imposes a C$6.002 million administrative monetary penalty. It says Binance failed to register as a foreign money services business and failed to report 5,902 large virtual currency transactions of C$10,000 or more between June 2021 and July 2023. FINTRAC says Binance officially ceased all Canadian operations on September 25, 2023 and was required to be registered until then.9

Binance has appealed the FINTRAC decision to Federal Court. This is a separate legal track under federal anti money laundering legislation and doesn’t determine the OSC Charter case.

FINTRAC Fines Binance $6M CAD for Compliance Failures captured the Canadian compliance overhang after the exchange had already announced its departure.

A company can stop onboarding customers, close a product or leave a jurisdiction. Regulators can still investigate conduct that occurred while the business was active there.

Regulators need records to reconstruct the past. Cross border platforms can spread staff, systems and legal entities across several countries. Without compulsory powers, investigators may struggle to establish who made a decision, which controls existed and what customers were told.

Broad demands carry real operating costs. A request covering years of email, chat, files and other communications can trigger preservation, data collection, legal review, privilege screening and cross border privacy work. A global exchange can spend heavily on that process. A smaller fintech may feel the same demand much more sharply.

Ontario’s Top Court Says the OSC Went Too Far November 2025

Binance tries several routes to challenge the investigation and summons. The Capital Markets Tribunal says it lacks jurisdiction to revoke them. The Divisional Court declines to decide the Charter challenge in the way Binance asks. The OSC itself later says it lacks jurisdiction to vary or revoke the summons. The Court of Appeal finally reaches the constitutional issue and sets the summons aside. The regulator can keep investigating, but it has to ask again within Charter limits.10

The ruling protects relevance, not secrecy. The Court accepts that regulators have strong production powers and that privacy expectations for regulated business records can be low. It still requires a reasonable basis to believe compelled records may matter to the investigation.

The OSC sees a wider enforcement problem. The regulator argues that the Court of Appeal’s approach could make investigations slower and more difficult, particularly before investigators know exactly where useful evidence sits. Binance answers that regulators have had relevance limits for decades and can draft demands around the conduct they are actually investigating.

A New Binance Inherits the Old Binance’s Problems 2023 to 2026

While Canadian courts examine the old Binance, regulatory pressure is forcing the company itself to change.

The pressure peaks in 2023. US regulators sue. Senior executives leave. Binance Faces Leadership Crisis as Top Executives Resign Amid Regulatory Pressure appears in July while the company is losing key legal, strategy and compliance leaders.

In November, Binance pleads guilty in the United States to criminal violations involving anti money laundering law, money transmission registration and sanctions. It agrees to pay US$4.3 billion, strengthen compliance and accept independent monitoring. Founder Changpeng Zhao pleads guilty to a separate Bank Secrecy Act offence and steps down as CEO.11

Richard Teng takes over. Binance establishes its first board. Licences, local entities and compliance spending move from the edges of the business model toward the centre.

The company that once treated regulatory borders as friction is rebuilding itself around them.

Inside Binance’s Post 2023 Compliance Rebuild

The Binance that emerges after the US settlement looks more like a conventional global financial company than the founder led organization regulators confronted earlier.

By December 2024, Teng said Binance had moved from a founder and CEO led structure to a board led model and held about 20 licences and registrations worldwide. Reuters reported that the company had created its first board and was still weighing a permanent global headquarters.12

Japan shows what that new approach can look like in practice. Binance didn’t simply keep serving local users from the global platform after regulator warnings. It bought a registered local exchange, launched Binance Japan and migrated users into the local structure.

At the end of 2025, Binance announced that its global platform had received authorization under Abu Dhabi Global Market’s regulatory framework. ADGM described it as the first crypto exchange to secure a formal global licence from its Financial Services Regulatory Authority.13

None of that erases earlier conduct or decides the Canadian case. Compliance has moved from something Binance repeatedly collided with into infrastructure it increasingly needs for market access.

The Binance Fight Becomes Bigger Than Crypto 2026

The Supreme Court grants the OSC leave to appeal on May 21. By October, the case has attracted groups that have little to do with crypto trading. The Court grants intervention rights to the attorneys general of Canada, Ontario, Quebec and British Columbia, the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, the British Columbia Securities Commission, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, the Canadian Constitution Foundation and Quebec’s workplace safety commission. It rejects several other applications, including the Canadian Forum for Financial Markets. The fight now reaches beyond one exchange. Section 8 of the Charter and the limits on compulsory record demands in regulated industries are at stake.

Investor protection still needs effective investigations. Regulators can’t police complex markets without access to records. Cross border digital businesses make that harder because relevant evidence may sit across entities, employees and systems that don’t line up neatly with one province.

Constitutional limits still matter inside regulated markets. Laura Paglia of the Canadian Forum for Financial Markets told Advisor.ca that securities regulators need broad powers, but argued that demands should remain proportionate and consider compliance costs. CFFiM was denied intervener status, so its view is industry commentary rather than a submission the Supreme Court will hear.14

The Company Left but the Regulatory Boundary Didn’t

Binance has already tried several endings in Canada.

First it left Ontario. Then it hired regulators and built an Alberta operation that was supposed to bring it back. Then it accepted an Ontario undertaking. Then it decided the national rules were no longer worth the trade and left Canada altogether.

The legal history kept going.

FINTRAC imposed a penalty tied to the years Binance operated here. Investors pursued a separate class action. Ontario courts rejected Binance’s attempt to force those investors into costly Hong Kong arbitration, a dispute later followed by Ontario Court Orders Binance To Pay Investor Legal Costs. The OSC kept investigating. The company that left Canada in 2023 is still litigating here in 2026.

Binance changed too. Zhao stepped down. A board arrived. Local licences and compliance teams became part of the growth strategy. Japan went from warning Binance to hosting a locally registered Binance business. Abu Dhabi became a regulated global base.

The Supreme Court case is now much bigger than Binance.

The Court is being asked to decide where constitutional limits sit when a regulator with legitimate investigative powers demands a very large volume of company records. A ruling that gives regulators wider latitude could make it easier to investigate complex businesses whose people, systems and data span multiple entities and countries. A ruling that requires a tighter connection between requested records and suspected conduct could force regulators to narrow summonses earlier and give companies stronger grounds to challenge sweeping demands.

Either way, the decision could shape how securities regulators design investigations, how regulated firms preserve and produce records, and how much compliance cost companies may face when regulators come looking for evidence. Depending on how broadly the Court reasons, its impact could also reach beyond capital markets into other regulated sectors that rely on statutory production powers.

That helps explain why governments, another securities regulator and civil liberties organizations have joined a dispute that began with one crypto exchange. The precedent could influence the balance between effective supervision and protection against regulatory overreach across Canadian business.

Binance spent years learning that global reach doesn’t erase national borders. Canada’s highest court is now deciding where one of those borders sits for regulators themselves.

Once a regulator has authority to investigate, how much of a company can it force open?

Binance left Canada. The company moved on. The answer could matter to regulated businesses long after this case is over.

Questions for Regulated Firms in Canada

  • How closely will regulators have to connect compelled records to the conduct they are investigating?
  • Will the Supreme Court give regulators more room to make broad document demands early in an investigation?
  • Could tighter limits on regulatory summonses change how firms preserve, retrieve and challenge record requests?
  • How much regulatory exposure survives after a company closes a product, changes ownership or exits a market?
  • Will firms operating in Canada need stronger record keeping, legal review and compliance infrastructure to respond to future regulatory demands?

Related NCFA Intelligence

INVESTOR GUIDE

7 Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Crypto Exchange in Canada

A current guide to registration, custody, transfers, funding, fees and operational risks Canadian investors should check before sending money to a crypto platform.

FINTECH INTELLIGENCE

Are Regulators Opening Markets While Raising Costs?

Market access can improve while evidence, records and supervision requirements get tougher, changing the economics for both incumbents and smaller entrants.

REGULATORY INSIGHT

Canada Proposes Stablecoin Market Entry Rules

Canada’s new stablecoin proposal shows how market access can depend on local custody, supervision and operating requirements, even when the underlying product is global.

REGULATION AND POLICY

National Security Is Now Part of Financial Supervision

Financial supervision is expanding beyond traditional capital and conduct questions into sanctions, cyber threats, ownership and state linked risk.


NCFA Canada logoThe National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, artificial intelligence, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

NCFA Financial Innovation MapNCFA Innovation Opportunity BriefsNCFA Fintech Insights
NCFA Fintech WhispererNCFA Fintech Fridays PodcastNCFA Weekly Newsletter

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *