Why Canada Took 8 Years to Unlock Fintech Investment

October 18, 2026 | NCFA Story Intelligence | Fintech Regulation, Financial Institutions, Investment and Competition
AI illustration of Canada's fintech investment reform delay from 2018 to 2026, showing banks, fintech sectors and broader investment opportunities.

Six Problems Behind Canada's Eight Year Fintech Investment Delay

On October 17, 2026, Finance Canada published proposed fintech investment and technology regulations for powers Parliament approved in June 2018 and never brought into force. The package reaches more than 400 federally regulated financial institutions.

Finance now says the older rules can “prevent or complicate” fintech investment, limit capital flowing into innovative sectors and impede productivity growth. Eight years after Parliament acted, the operating rules are still only proposed.

The delay wasn’t one long consultation. Finance’s own record shows six concrete problems. Officials had to draw the regulatory perimeter between finance and technology, preserve the barrier against unrelated commerce, set revenue and regulatory capital limits, stop the rules from squeezing smaller institutions, and cut reporting requirements industry said were too heavy. Then Parliament had to repair defects in the 2018 statute in 2024. Six problems turned one reform into eight years of rulemaking.

This wasn’t a ban on fintech investment. Banks and insurers could still buy businesses that fit the existing rules. The trouble started when a fintech mixed finance with commercial software or expanded after an institution had invested. Banks had already warned that some domestic technology approvals took three to four months. The 2026 proposal would finally give qualifying mixed businesses a new route when at least 60% of their activity is financial, subject to separate limits on the investor.

Finance opened the review in 2016. It held 32 meetings and received 63 written submissions, then received 300 submissions in 2017, with 25 focused on fintech. Finance later acknowledged that incumbent institutions and industry associations were better represented than independent fintechs and venture investors.

Bankers came with a practical complaint. The Canadian Bankers Association’s 2017 submission said some domestic technology approvals could take three to four months and covered only the activities named in the application. That’s a poor fit for a fintech that can add a product, market or subsidiary in the time it takes a large institution to finish an approval process.

Fintechs Start Crossing The Old Regulatory Lines 2016 to 2017

Founders weren’t building tidy regulatory categories. Payments were moving into merchant software, identity tools could serve banks and law offices, and data companies were becoming financial infrastructure while selling into other industries. The old rules drew cleaner lines than the market did.

Investors wanted a wider lane too. Finance said collaboration could pair fintech speed with the balance sheets and customer relationships of established institutions. Portag3 Ventures, then backing Canadian companies including Wealthsimple, Borrowell and KOHO, supported broader investment flexibility and argued that bank financing and collaboration were important to the fintech ecosystem. Capital and distribution were already part of the policy problem.

Under the Bank Act route described by the CBA, a substantial investment generally had to stay inside permitted activities. If even one ancillary activity or a downstream subsidiary moved outside that list, the bank could face another approval, a different investment classification or divestment. The CBA called the restriction a “significant impediment” with the potential to restrict Canadian innovation.

Insurers ran into the same boundary from another direction. The life insurance industry’s 2017 submission said an insurer could use identity or anti money laundering technology inside finance but couldn’t freely sell the same capability to law offices, real estate firms, other businesses or government. Useful technology could have a broader market, while the ownership and commercialization rules stayed narrow.

Growth Can Turn A Bank Investor Into A Constraint 2017

A growing fintech can create a problem for the shareholder that helped fund it. Add inventory software, merchant analytics or a commercial subsidiary because customers want them, and the business may no longer fit the permission that supported the original bank investment. The CBA warned that this could discourage fintechs from working with banks.

Insurers faced a similar commercial choice. A tool built for regulated finance might have customers far beyond finance, yet the legal route could narrow who could own the business or where the product could be sold. That can influence which investor a founder takes, how the company is structured and which markets it enters next.

How could the old rules change a founder’s decision?

A founder weighing a new product couldn’t look only at customer demand. If the activity fell outside a bank investor’s permitted business, expansion could trigger another approval, a different investment classification or a divestment decision. The investor that helped finance growth could become a constraint on the next stage of growth.

No named transaction has been documented as abandoned for this reason. That doesn’t erase the mechanism recorded in the 2017 submission, because a weak legal fit can kill an idea before anyone files an application. Venture investors weren’t subject to the same federal financial institution business powers.

Parliament responded on June 21, 2018. The 2018 Budget Implementation Act broadened permitted technology activities, removed prior ministerial approval for the expanded nonfinancial activities, widened referral powers and created a new investment category for companies whose businesses were mostly financial services. The law clearly moved toward more flexibility.

But Parliament didn’t define how much of a company had to be financial to qualify as a majority financial services entity. It also left the revenue, capital, reporting and transaction conditions to regulation. Without those operating rules, institutions couldn’t use the new powers and stayed under the older framework.

Parliament Approves The Powers. The Operating Rules Don’t Follow. June 2018

Parliament gave banks and insurers broader ownership powers in June 2018. Finance still had to define the majority test, exposure limits and safeguards before anyone could use them. The authority existed. The investment route didn’t.

That left financial institutions making real investment decisions under the old framework while fintech business models kept widening. A company could fit the rules when a bank first invested and create a new legal problem later simply by adding a commercial activity customers wanted.

What exactly did Parliament approve in 2018?

The amendments expanded the information and technology activities federally regulated financial institutions could conduct. They also widened referral and agency powers, removed ministerial approval from the new permitted nonfinancial activities and created a majority financial services investment category. The direction was broader participation, not unrestricted commercial ownership.

The new category was meant for businesses that were primarily financial but also did other commercial work. Parliament supplied the authority but not the operating definition of majority or the limits around its use. Finance still had to turn the statute into rules a transaction team could actually use.

After Royal Assent, Finance worked with the CBA, the Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association and OSFI. The first problem was the regulatory perimeter. Finance called separating new technology activities from core financial services a “serious technical challenge”, especially when the same staff, assets and systems served both. Officials also had to preserve existing investment prohibitions and keep visibility into the new business.

Then came the operating limits. In 2019, officials worked through revenue caps, regulatory capital exposure, annual reports and transaction conditions. A 2020 technical review exposed two more problems. Uniform rules could box out smaller institutions, while the proposed reporting package could impose a significant burden. Finance later revised both.

Six Problems Stretch One Reform Across Eight Years 2018 to 2026

The delay didn’t come from one unresolved issue. It came from six. Finance had to separate finance from technology, preserve limits on unrelated commerce, set revenue and capital exposure caps, give smaller institutions enough room to compete, and reduce reporting requirements industry said were too burdensome. Those were the five regulatory design problems documented through the consultation record.

The sixth problem sat in the law itself. Bill C-59 received Royal Assent in June 2024 and made technical corrections to the 2018 law. It fixed discrepancies between the English and French provisions and clarified that the expanded technology powers were limited to information technology. By then, Finance had already consulted in 2019, reviewed a draft in 2020, consulted again in 2021 and returned with another draft in 2024.

Every revision created another round of legal or regulatory work. Caps changed. Reporting changed. Parliament repaired the statute six years after passage. The first public regulations still didn’t reach Canada Gazette Part I until October 2026, even though stakeholders were asking by 2024 for the powers to come into force “as soon as feasible.”

What happened between 2018 and 2026?

Finance began implementation work after Royal Assent in 2018. By early 2019, discussions had expanded to revenue and capital limits, reporting and transaction conditions. The initiative entered Finance Canada’s fintech regulatory implementation plan in July 2020, followed by further consultations on regulatory parameters in summer 2021.

The 2020 technical review found problems with the treatment of smaller institutions and the reporting burden. Finance revised the caps and streamlined reporting before consulting again in 2024. Parliament enacted the technical statutory corrections that June. Canada Gazette Part I finally published the regulatory draft on October 17, 2026.

The market didn’t wait for the rulebook. By 2019, one industry study counted roughly 1,000 Canadian fintech companies, more than 30,000 employees and about C$30.5 billion in startup value. Founders, banks and investors kept building around the permissions they actually had.

National Bank took control of Flinks in 2021. Its disclosed transaction included C$73 million for voting preferred shares followed by another C$30 million investment. The bank’s interest rose to 85.9%.

RBC bought WayPay in 2019 to expand automated business payments and account reconciliation. Canada Life acquired ClaimSecure in 2021, adding 1.25 million plan members and technology handling more than C$1.2 billion in annual claims payments. Canada Life and ClaimSecure later launched a combined benefits product.

Flinks, WayPay And ClaimSecure Move Ahead Under The Old Rules 2019 to 2026

Those deals matter because they rule out the easy story. Canada didn’t ban institutional fintech investment, and banks and insurers kept buying businesses that fit the existing framework. The squeeze showed up at the edges, where finance blended with commercial activity or a company later expanded beyond the legal fit that supported the original investment.

By October 2026, Flinks had moved beyond financial data connectivity into banking development, payment integrations, account switching and managed services. That’s exactly the kind of expansion a strategic shareholder may want to keep backing. Under the older framework, a different commercial move could force the shareholder to stop and ask whether it could legally stay invested.

What did the companies actually disclose?

National Bank’s 2021 results disclosed the Flinks transaction. RBC described its WayPay acquisition as part of expanding digital capabilities for commercial clients. These deals establish what the old framework could accommodate.

Canada Life’s ClaimSecure acquisition added 1.25 million plan members, while the later SecurePak launch combined ClaimSecure technology with Canada Life products. None of these transactions has been established as a special exemption connected to the dormant 2018 amendments. They’re examples of what was possible, not proof that the restrictions never bit elsewhere.

The CBA warned that the legal fit could affect a deal before anyone applied for approval. If a fintech needed capital quickly, a bank bid carrying a regulatory condition could lose to cleaner, faster money. A later business change could also force the bank back into approval or divestment. A lost opportunity can disappear before Ottawa ever sees a file.

Finance expects more activity once the new route is usable. Over the past decade, roughly one institution per year sought the relevant ministerial approvals. Finance now assumes large banks will average two qualifying investments annually and large insurers one. The figures aren’t directly comparable, but Finance itself expects more activity because the process should be faster, less costly and more certain.

The Deals That Never Reach Ottawa Leave No File 2018 to 2026

Government data can count approvals. It can’t count the bank bid that was never made, the expansion pushed into another company or the investor a founder never approached because the legal fit was poor. It can’t count technology an insurer decided not to sell outside finance either. Those decisions rarely leave a public record.

The economic toll starts before an approval file exists. A bank offer with conditions can lose to faster capital. A founder can split a product, delay a commercial move or avoid an investor whose ownership may become a future constraint. None of those choices needs a rejection letter to change the company’s path.

Which business models were most exposed to the old boundary?

The businesses under the most pressure were the ones mixing finance with something else. Embedded finance can combine payments or lending with merchant software. Identity, fraud and compliance tools can sell to banks, retailers, law offices and governments. AI and data companies can support financial decisions while building a much wider enterprise market.

Research published in 2019 linked Canada’s financial services productivity gap to restrictive regulation that weakened competition, capital formation and fintech scaling. It also noted that the investment reforms already passed still lacked clarity and an effective date. The report didn’t isolate the dormant 2018 amendments as a standalone productivity cost, but the implementation gap was visible years before the 2026 proposal.

The October proposal finally puts a number on majority. A target can qualify when at least 60% of its business consists of qualifying financial activity, measured using whichever produces the highest result among revenue, operating expenses or assets. That gives younger or differently structured companies more than one way to clear the test.

The investor has separate limits. Institutions with more than C$12 billion in equity would face a 10% nonfinancial revenue ceiling and a 10% regulatory capital exposure limit. Small and medium institutions with C$12 billion or less in equity would get 15% revenue headroom while keeping the same 10% capital limit.

The 60% Test Gives Mixed Fintechs A New Route October 2026

Take a payments company that also sells merchant software. Under the older activity based route, one impermissible commercial activity could knock the company out of that investment permission. Under the proposal, a business with 70% qualifying financial activity and 30% other commercial activity could potentially qualify. The 70 and 30 split is illustrative, but the business consequence is straightforward. The founder may no longer have to strip out every useful commercial feature just to keep a bank investor eligible.

The percentages don’t describe the same limit. The historical 5% exemption covered certain bank technology investments without approval and required the investee to stay within prescribed activities. The new 60% test applies to the target company’s business mix. The 10% and 15% limits apply to the investing institution’s aggregate nonfinancial business. There isn’t a simple old cap and new cap comparison.

What investment and expansion choices could change?

The examples below put the rule into business terms. They’re illustrations of how an investment decision could change, not transactions proven to have been blocked. Securities, digital assets, privacy, lending, payments and insurance rules still apply on top of the new investment permissions.

Fintech investment example Existing framework Proposed permissions
Payments and merchant software A bank can own permitted payments or technology activities, but a fintech adding inventory management or merchant retail operations outside those permissions may become harder to acquire or retain. A bank could potentially invest in the combined payments and merchant software company when the target meets the 60% financial activity test and the bank stays within its own limits.
Lending, embedded finance and SME platforms A platform mixing lending or payments with booking, loyalty or other commercial software can fall outside an existing investment route when an impermissible activity sits in the target or a subsidiary. The mixed business route could make a qualifying embedded finance platform eligible without stripping out every commercial feature. Lending and consumer protection rules would still apply.
Digital identity, fraud and RegTech An insurer can use or license some compliance technology within finance, while its 2017 industry submission identified limits on selling the same technology to law offices, real estate firms and other nonfinancial customers. Broader technology permissions could support identity verification, fraud checks and compliance software used across industries, subject to the statutory boundaries and applicable approvals.
Insurance and health benefits technology An insurer can already acquire eligible insurance businesses, as Canada Life did with ClaimSecure. Commercial activity beyond the permitted business can still change what an insurer may own or sell. A mixed insurance technology company could be easier to acquire if its qualifying financial activity clears the majority test. Commercial activity would still count toward the institution's limits.
AI and financial data tools Banks can develop and buy permitted financial analytics. A fintech expanding into general retail or enterprise AI may cross the investor's activity permissions or require another legal structure. Expanded technology permissions or the majority financial services route could support a wider product mix. Privacy, AI and sector rules would remain separate.
Wealth technology and investing platforms A digital wealth platform may fit an existing financial investment route, while broader enterprise analytics or commercial software can complicate that route if the activities move outside permitted business. A qualifying wealth platform could combine investment services with a larger adjacent technology offering if it clears the majority test and the investor stays within its limits. Securities registration would remain separate.
Blockchain and tokenized asset infrastructure The insurance industry cited distributed ledger software for asset managers as a financial technology example in 2017. That did not make every blockchain or token business an eligible investment. A bank or insurer may have more flexibility to invest in financial ledger software, asset servicing or a mixed technology provider when its actual activities qualify. Securities and custody rules remain separate.
Tokenized deposits and settlement Banks can already develop permitted deposit and settlement products. Canada's major banks are exploring tokenized deposits, so the dormant 2018 amendments were not a proven block to those projects. Broader investment powers could support qualifying software providers, service companies and partnerships around tokenized banking infrastructure without changing the legal treatment of deposits.
Crypto platforms and stablecoin services An exchange, custody business or stablecoin issuer does not become an eligible bank investment simply because it uses software or blockchain. Securities, prudential and other restrictions still matter. The proposal creates no blanket crypto permission. A specific business model would still need to satisfy the investment test and every other applicable regulatory requirement.
Crowdfunding and private capital markets A financing platform may qualify as a financial business, but unrelated marketplace or software activity can complicate a financial institution investment under the existing activity tests. A platform combining qualifying financial activity with commercial software could potentially fit the new category. Crowdfunding exemptions and securities rules would still apply.
Customer referrals and SME software Existing bank referral powers are principally framed around financial service providers, limiting some referrals into broader commercial platforms. Expanded referral powers could let a bank connect customers with eligible funding, invoicing and business software providers. Referral permission remains distinct from acquisition permission.

The insurance industry’s 2017 submission specifically cited distributed ledger software for asset managers. That supports a blockchain infrastructure example, not a claim that every crypto business suddenly becomes investable. Canadian banks are already exploring Canadian dollar tokenized deposits under existing powers, while distributed ledger businesses still face securities law where it applies.

If an institution breaches either aggregate limit, affected holdings can become temporary investments, generally giving it two years to return to compliance or move the holding into another permitted category. The route is wider, but it isn’t a licence for banks or insurers to own any commercial business they want.

More eligible bank and insurer investors can improve financing choices, distribution and negotiating leverage for an independent fintech. A strategic buyer can get a product in front of customers much faster. It can also end up owning technology several competing institutions rely on. More capital and more competition aren’t automatically the same outcome.

Finance is trying to keep sight of that risk. Certain large acquirers would have to report material supply arrangements between a target and the acquirer’s competitors. Smaller and medium institutions get more revenue headroom and no new reports, because identical limits would leave them with much less room to compete.

More Bank Capital Can Also Mean More Bank Control 2017 to 2026

A wider buyer pool can help founders raise money, get distribution and negotiate exits. It can also put an important supplier or emerging challenger inside a major incumbent. That’s where the reform shifts from a capital question to a competition question.

The Competition Bureau’s fintech study supported removing unnecessary barriers to entry and collaboration while keeping scrutiny where incumbent relationships could weaken competition. Finance’s new supply reporting reflects the same concern. The useful outcome isn’t simply more acquisitions. It’s more capital reaching strong companies without draining independent competitive pressure from the market.

How could smaller financial institutions compete?

Finance initially considered common limits, then found that a 10% revenue cap would leave smaller institutions with far less absolute capacity than the largest banks and insurers. Institutions with C$12 billion or less in equity therefore get a 15% revenue allowance, while everyone keeps the 10% regulatory capital limit. The extra room is meant to keep the reform from becoming a tool only the biggest institutions can use.

Small and medium institutions are also exempt from the new transaction and annual reports. That cuts a burden Finance itself concluded would fall harder on them. Whether the design works will show up in what smaller banks, trusts and insurers actually back once the powers are active.

Finance estimates the proposed rules will add C$267,518 in annualized administrative and compliance costs, or about C$1.88 million in present value over 10 years. Those figures cover the new reporting burden. They don’t count the savings from removing some ministerial approvals, and they certainly don’t capture eight years of slower, narrower business choices under the old framework.

The regulations are proposed, not in force. Canada Gazette Part I opened a 30 day consultation on October 17, 2026, with comments due November 16. The government still has to finalize the regulations and use a separate Order in Council to activate the dormant 2018 amendments.

Eight Years Later, The Powers Still Aren’t Active October to November 2026

The last round now turns on execution. The 60% definition has to work for current fintech business models, smaller institutions need enough room to compete, and Finance needs visibility into new risks without rebuilding the reporting burden industry spent years pushing back on. Get those choices wrong and the reform can still underdeliver even after eight years.

Canada has already spent eight years designing conditions around powers Parliament approved in 2018. The next step is simpler to describe and harder to deliver. Put the rules into force, give good businesses a workable path to institutional capital, and keep enough independent competition in the market that customers actually benefit.

What should fintechs and investors watch before the rules are finalized?

The 60% definition decides which mixed businesses can qualify. Revenue and capital caps decide how much room an institution has to use the powers. Subsidiary treatment, reporting exemptions and supply relationships will affect how easily deals can be structured and how closely Finance can watch competition risk.

The proposal doesn’t erase the basic policy choice behind Canada’s banking system. Banks and insurers still have to remain primarily financial businesses. What changes is the hard edge around mixed companies. Some commercial activity around finance would no longer automatically push a promising fintech outside the investment route.

Canada’s eight year delay carried a real economic toll. Banks faced approval processes that could take three to four months. Mixed fintechs could lose access to some bank or insurer investors as they expanded. Insurers had less room to sell useful technology outside financial services. Finance now says the old framework can prevent or complicate investment, limit capital and impede productivity. We can’t put a credible dollar figure on every deal, product or expansion that went another way, but the commercial cost isn’t abstract. It lands in who funds a company, what it builds next and how quickly it gets to market.

Canada has good reasons to keep banks and insurers out of unrelated commerce. Those guardrails protect stability and stop financial institutions from controlling too much of the wider economy. But a safeguard carries a cost when rules written for older business models keep constraining newer ones after Parliament has already approved change. The Competition Bureau’s fintech progress review has warned that regulatory barriers can weaken competition too. Capital won’t wait eight years for rulemaking to catch up.

Founders didn’t stop building while Ottawa worked through the rules. Banks and insurers still found ways to invest where the old framework allowed it, as Flinks, WayPay and ClaimSecure show. The 2026 proposal can widen those paths without turning strategic investment into another route to incumbent control. Eight years are gone. The better outcome now is a market where good Canadian fintechs have more ways to finance growth, commercialize useful technology and challenge the status quo.


NCFA Canada logoThe National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, artificial intelligence, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

NCFA Financial Innovation MapNCFA Innovation Opportunity BriefsNCFA Fintech Insights
NCFA Fintech WhispererNCFA Fintech Fridays PodcastNCFA Weekly Newsletter

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *