Karsten Wenzlaff, Advisor
August 26th, 2025
November 4, 2026 | NCFA Story Intelligence | Sustainable Finance And ESG, Regulation And Policy, Competition And Market Structure

ESG ratings promised investors a shortcut.
Instead of digging through climate data, labour records, governance practices and supply chains themselves, they could buy a score and put it to work.
Then the scores started disagreeing.
The same company could look strong through one provider and much weaker through another. Nobody had to be cheating or doing bad work. One firm might care more about carbon exposure. Another might put more weight on labour practices, board governance or supply chains. Even when they looked at the same issue, they weren't always using the same data.
Investors were left with a problem. They had bought a shortcut and now had to check the shortcut.
In Britain, thousands of financial firms eventually built their own checks around ratings they were already paying for. The FCA estimates that extra work now costs about £495 million every year.
Regulators eventually made a choice that wasn't obvious at the start. They didn't force every provider to use the same formula. They started regulating the firms producing the ratings.
The EU rules have applied since July 2, 2026. On November 3, 2026, the UK Financial Conduct Authority published its final ESG ratings rules. From June 29, 2028, firms caught by the UK regime need FCA authorisation.
Canada hasn't followed them.
That gives a Canadian startup more breathing room at home.
Then it lands a customer in London, Paris or Frankfurt.
The Canadian rules haven't changed. The business suddenly has.
One provider knocks a company down for carbon exposure. The investor sees the score fall and assumes climate risk is driving the result. But that number also reflects choices about which indicators were used, which data was trusted and how the provider turned those inputs into a score.
Another barely moves on carbon but cuts the same company for governance or labour practices. The company itself hasn't changed between the two ratings. What changed is the lens used to judge it. Same company. Same ESG label. Different story.
Providers sign up, publish more detail and tighten their controls. They still get to build their own methods and scores. That keeps room for different models to compete, but it also leaves customers comparing very different ways of measuring the same company.
Customers keep doing their own checks anyway. Banks, asset managers and other users still have to decide whether the provider's data, methodology and controls are strong enough for their own decisions. More disclosure helps, but the doubt doesn't go away.
A rating only saves time if the buyer trusts the data, methodology and controls used to produce it. By this point, many firms aren't simply reading the score. They're reviewing the provider, checking the method and sometimes changing their own systems before the rating can be used.
By 2025, thousands of firms have built their own second opinion inside the company. Some are spending months onboarding providers and assigning staff just to close information gaps or resolve concerns before a rating can be trusted. The shortcut has created another job.
Before, a provider could follow the voluntary code and convince customers that its controls were good enough. The customer could accept that explanation, ask for more or walk away. The regulator wasn't deciding whether the provider could stay in the market.
Under FCA rules, that choice disappears. Firms in scope have to meet requirements around governance, conflicts, systems, data and disclosure, and they need authorisation to keep serving the market. If the firm is caught by the regime, meeting the standard becomes part of staying in business.
A smaller Canadian provider can still reach European customers without waiting for Canada to create its own ratings licence. Recognition can give qualifying foreign firms a way in when equivalence isn't available, so the market isn't closed to an independent Canadian provider.
But it still has to meet European requirements. Depending on the route, that can mean a legal representative, added documentation and direct accountability to ESMA. The company can stay Canadian, but its European business can't simply run on Canadian rules. Getting into the market is possible. Getting in on Canadian terms isn't.
A Canadian startup can build an ESG scoring product, test it and sell it at home without first getting a dedicated ratings licence. That leaves more of its early budget for product, data, hiring and customers instead of a new authorisation process.
Then it signs a foreign customer. New legal work, documentation, controls and regulatory relationships can arrive with the contract even though the product itself is unchanged. The product hasn't changed. The cost of selling it may have.
The Canada EU digital trade deal can make contracts, permitted data transfers and online delivery easier for smaller Canadian companies. That can remove friction from how a digital service is sold and delivered across the Atlantic.
If the product is an ESG rating, ESMA's rules still apply. A smoother digital sale doesn't replace recognition, endorsement or any other requirement that applies to the provider itself. The sale may get easier. The regulatory work doesn't disappear.
Providers still get to disagree and build different models. One can give climate more weight while another puts more emphasis on governance, and the FCA doesn't try to choose the winner.
What changes is how much of the work behind the score has to stand up to scrutiny. Providers have to explain more about the data, methods, conflicts and controls that produced the result. The rating can stay subjective. The process can't stay hidden.
UK applications begin in 2027. Firms expecting at least £500,000 in ESG ratings revenue over the following 12 months apply first. Smaller providers follow. For a Canadian exporter, the size and timing of the sales pipeline can therefore affect when the FCA application work starts.
A firm serving both the UK and EU can reuse some people, controls and documentation. That should keep the second market from starting entirely from zero, but the two regimes remain separate and each still has its own entry requirements. It can reuse the work. It can't reuse the permission.
Canada gets a real benefit from staying lighter.
A young ratings or analytics company can spend more of its first dollars on product, hiring and customers instead of building a licence around a market that may still be small.
That works well while Canada is the market.
Then the company wants to scale.
A UK customer can bring FCA requirements into the sales process. A European customer can bring ESMA. The Canadian company starts hiring compliance staff, changing contracts, documenting methods and adding controls that Canada never asked it to build.
Copying the UK or EU isn't an obvious answer either.
A Canadian licence would cost money. Plenty of firms may never need one. Large global providers can spread that cost across thousands of customers. A startup can't.
But staying different isn't automatically free.
If every Canadian firm with global ambitions has to build around foreign rules anyway, Canada's lighter model starts saving less than it first appears.
Canada hasn't crossed that line by law. Some Canadian firms may cross it much sooner.
At what point does regulatory divergence stop saving Canadian firms money and start making international expansion more complicated?
Ottawa hasn't answered that question. Canadian firms trying to sell abroad may answer it first.
Share this story → Explore related intelligence → Subscribe
The National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, artificial intelligence, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
|---|---|---|
![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
Leave a Reply