Global fintech and funding innovation ecosystem

Category Archives: Digital, NEO, Open Banking, Open Finance

CFPB’s New Rule Boosts Open Banking Standards

Open Banking Jun 12, 2024

Freepik data sharing rights - CFPB's New Rule Boosts Open Banking Standards

Image: Freepik

CFPB Publishes Final Rule on Personal Financial Data Rights

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) has published final rules for personal financial data rights (PDF)| Newsroom announcement, which focuses on recognizing industry standard-setting groups.  The approved rule is a part of a larger initiative to enhance consumer's control over their financial data and promote open banking by implementing Section 1033 of the customer Financial Protection Act.  Here's what you need to know.

10 Takeways

1.  The final regulation will go into force on July 11, 2024. This gives companies one month to get ready for compliance.

2.  The rule lays out the procedure by which industry organizations can be recognized by the CFPB. Consensus standards will be created by recognized organizations to help with the new Personal Financial Data Rights rule's compliance. The CFPB also released this guide.

3.  Five essential characteristics that standard-setting bodies must exhibit are: transparency, openness, balance, due process and appeals, and consensus. These characteristics ensure fairness, inclusivity, and transparency of the standards that are set.

See:  Open Banking: Revolutionizing Financial Data Sharing

4.  This is an open role opportunity.  All interested parties, including consumer advocacy organizations, app developers, and different financial institutions, must have access to the processes and procedures of standard-setting bodies. Because of its diversity, no one group is able to dominate the market.

5.  To prevent any one group from dominating, decisions must take into account the interests of all parties involved. Meaningful representation from both big and small entities must be part of any decisions.

6. Rather than being created by unanimity, standards must be formed by universal agreement (consensus standards). This guarantees that every opinion is taken into account while creating standards.

7.  Accredited organizations are required to have written, publicly accessible policies as well as equitable procedures for hearing appeals and settling disputes. This includes providing sufficient notice of meetings and time for review and objections as per this MortgagePoint article.

8.  Transparent methods must be used to create standards which must be open to the public. As stated by American Banker, "this transparency is crucial for maintaining trust and ensuring that the standards are developed openly."

9.  Organizations must reapply for standards accreditation after their five-year recognition period is over. This recurring evaluation makes sure that the requirements are met throughout time and that the criteria are still applicable.

See:  Open Banking Regulation in the U.S. Strikes a Chord

10.  The rule lays the groundwork for future rules that will rely on these acknowledged standards, even if it does not impose any immediate costs for compliance. It is recommended that financial institutions and fintech startups are ready to comply with these agreed norms in the future.

Rohit Chopra, CFPB Director:

"Industry standards can be weaponized by dominant firms to maintain their market position, undermining competition for all. Today's rule will prevent these firms from rigging standards in their favor by identifying attributes the CFPB will use to recognize standard setters"​

Freepik tonodiaz digital tablet at work - CFPB's New Rule Boosts Open Banking Standards

Image: Freepik/tonodiaz

Implications of CFPBs Final Rule

CFPBs final rule on personal financial data rights is a big step towards open banking and open finance in the US.  Here's what it means to various stakeholders.

Empowerment (Control), Access and Potential Cost Savings for Consumers

  • Thanks to the ability to share their financial information with fintech companies and other third parties for individualized financial services, customers have more control over their financial information.

See:  Credit Reference Agencies Are Coming For Your Data

  • Boosts financial inclusion by providing underprivileged communities with access to specialized financial services via fintech innovation and open banking.
  • The rule aims to lower long-term costs and improve efficiency through uniform methods, but it does impose certain early expenses on industry participants. Consumers may benefit from these cost savings, which would increase the accessibility and affordability of financial services.

Fintechs

  • The rule gives fintechs the chance to innovate and provide services that are competitive by allowing data sharing. By having direct access to customer data, smaller fintech businesses can better compete with larger incumbents in the market.
  • Fintechs must make sure that the new standards are followed, which will come with compliance costs and the creation of safe data-sharing solutions.

Financial Institutions

  • To comply, banks and other financial organizations must adjust their data-sharing procedures to comply with new rules and accepted norms. To be competitive, this may require more tech expenses and potentially a new business strategy.
  • According to American Banker, the law permits banks to charge reasonable fees to third parties for access to their data, which helps them defray the expenses of compliance and data security improvements.

See:  2023 Data Privacy in North America – Year in Review

  • The rule requires standard-setting organizations to have open and honest procedures, guaranteeing that customers are aware of the uses and sharing of their data. This boosts confidence in the banking sector

Standard Setting Groups

  • The rule outlines the requirements for being recognized as a body that sets standards, placing a strong emphasis on openness, balance, due process, consensus, and transparency. These organizations will be essential in creating and upholding the industry standards.
  • To make sure that standards keep up with developments in the market and with emerging technologies, recognized bodies are required to go through periodic assessments every five years.

Outlook

It is anticipated that CFPBs new rule will promote innovation, increase consumer empowerment, and guarantee equitable competition between fintech startups and financial institutions.


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - CFPB's New Rule Boosts Open Banking StandardsThe National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, artificial intelligence, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

Latest news - CFPB's New Rule Boosts Open Banking StandardsFF Logo 400 v3 - CFPB's New Rule Boosts Open Banking Standardscommunity social impact - CFPB's New Rule Boosts Open Banking Standards

Support NCFA by Following us on Twitter!







NCFA Sign up for our newsletter - CFPB's New Rule Boosts Open Banking Standards




 

Zum Rails’ Major AI-Driven BaaS Initiative and Strategic Hire

Release | Jun 7, 2024

Zum rails - Zum Rails' Major AI-Driven BaaS Initiative and Strategic Hire

Image: Zūm logo

Zūm Rails hires Miro Pavletic to lead new AI-driven banking project

A scaling Canadian fintech business Zūm Rails has announced the hiring of Miro Pavletic who joins Zūm to manage its large-scale AI-driven Banking-as-a-Service (BaaS) project. This is a key move to expand Zūm Rails' unique financial offerings and solutions.

Miro Pavletic

Fintech expert with a wealth of banking and finance experience, Miro Pavletic joins Zūm Rails as a key player in their newest project. Previously, Pavletic was the Co-founder and CEO of Stack, a digital challenger banking app that was acquired by Credit Sesame in 2020.

See:  Züm Rails’ $10.5M Boost for North American Expansion

Pavletic will lead Zūm Rails’ BaaS product roadmap, which will integrate with Zūm Rail’s current payment services and include real-time fraud assessment, identity validation, and transaction settlement capabilities. Pavletic is committed to accelerating the development and implementation of these features on a unified platform, enabling businesses to surpass regulators' open banking deadlines and utilize artificial intelligence to effectively manage risk.

Key Developments and Financing

Since founding in 2019 Zūm Rails self-funded its way to profitability and has become a significant player in the North American payments market. Their 'omni-rail' solution combines instant payments with open banking to create a streamlined transaction process that supports multiple payment methods like Visa Direct, Mastercard, direct bank account linking, and Canada's Interac network.

In February of this year, Zūm Rails was in the spotlight when it successfully completing a $10.5 million CAD Series A fundraising round led by Arthur Ventures. The purpose of this capital infusion was to strengthen their open banking and quick payment capabilities, as well as to increase their market share in the United States.  The company intends to launch new BaaS capabilities and a FedNow service in the United States that will allow companies to process FDIC-insured payments in a matter of seconds.

See:  Implications of the BaaS Synapse Collapse

Firms like Plaid, Finicity, and established banks that are pursuing open banking are a few of Zūm's core competitors. Zūm Rails stands out in a crowded market thanks to its seamless integration of quick payments and open banking. This is the core of its unique value offer (in a fragmented market).

Closing Outlook

Zūm Rails is in a strong position to grow its market share and accelerate its creative activities, thanks to the smart hiring of Miro Pavletic and recent funding injection. As Zūm continues to innovate, stakeholders can expect a wave of new developments that will enhance the efficiency, security, and scope of financial transactions across North America.


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - Zum Rails' Major AI-Driven BaaS Initiative and Strategic HireThe National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, artificial intelligence, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

Latest news - Zum Rails' Major AI-Driven BaaS Initiative and Strategic HireFF Logo 400 v3 - Zum Rails' Major AI-Driven BaaS Initiative and Strategic Hirecommunity social impact - Zum Rails' Major AI-Driven BaaS Initiative and Strategic Hire

Support NCFA by Following us on Twitter!







NCFA Sign up for our newsletter - Zum Rails' Major AI-Driven BaaS Initiative and Strategic Hire




 

Implications of the BaaS Synapse Collapse

BaaS | May 29, 2024

Freepik yanalya bankruptcy shock - Implications of the BaaS Synapse Collapse

Image: Freepik/yanalya

The Synapse Collapse and What It Means for up to 10 Million Consumers and the Fintech Industry

Synapse's shutdown is sending ripples throughout the fintech space

The fintech sector has been rocked in recent weeks by the failure of Synapse Financial Technologies, which has surfaced huge issues within the fintech sector’s Banking-as-a-Service (BaaS) model of doing business. Synapse, a high profile BaaS player backed by Andreessen Horowitz (a16z) filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in late-April 2024, potentially affecting up to 10 million consumers per TechCrunch.  So lots of customers are unable to access their funds exposing vulnerabilities within the BaaS middleware model providing crucial lessons for the entire fintech ecosystem.

Banking-as-a-service (BaaS)

Banking-as-a-service (BaaS) is the delivery of banking services in partnership between a licensed bank and a fintech or nonbank entity. By and large, the services offered are a range of online banking, payment processing, money transfer, lending, and tools to help budget, save, and invest. BaaS allows fintech firms to innovate at speed and to provide financial services at a lower cost of entry. BaaS does have additional risks in the areas of compliance, security, and operational resilience.

What caused the collapse?

Synapse's failure can be attributed to a number of operational and partnership issues. Among these was a €13 million deficient reconciliation problem with its major banking partner, Evolve Bank & Trust, highlighting inherent risks where middleware can delay real-time financial reconciliation.  This was further complicated by Synapse using For Benefit Of Accounts (FBO),a common setup with BaaS firms where FBO accounts hold customer funds under a single account on behalf of multiple end-users, which made reconciliation and tracking of customer funds more difficult.

See:  Bank-Fintech Partnerships and Trends 2024

To add fuel to the fire, there was a lack of proper management of such technological and operational bugs which eventually resulted in the freezing of the accounts of Synapse as well as the winding up of its operations. So millions of end customers across a variety of fintech applications like Juno, Yotta, and Copper woke up one day and were denied access to their accounts, with no apparent solution in the near term.  For customers, it is a cautionary tale of the risks involved when banking with fintech company relying on a BaaS model.

Industry Implications

The implications for the fintech industry and its investors are significant.

  • Greater regulatory scrutiny is also likely to follow, with regulators possibly seeking to impose greater constraints to hold fintech companies to account to high expectations of compliance and risk management.
  • Andreessen Horowitz, a leading investor in Synapse, and other investors are now cautious and applying more rigor to the commercial sustainability and risk mitigation systems of BaaS providers. There may be less money on offer for new fintech startups and a more risk-averse strategy towards investment.

See:  Bain & Co Embedded Finance Report: What It Takes to Prosper in the New Value Chain

  • The failure has also sparked a debate as to whether such failures are the nature of the BaaS model or whether such shortcomings can be averted by more effective governance and operational controls.  Experts are of the opinion that while the BaaS model itself is not having any fundamental flaw, management of partnership workings, and particularly with banking institutions, has to be managed closely.
  • Fintech companies must work out sound reconciliation process, maintain frank communications with banking partners and ensure fulfillment of regulatory requirement.
  • Consolidations and M&A may increase across the market as smaller struggling companies are forced out of the market or into the arms of larger, stronger companies, leaving fewer but more robust providers of BaaS.

Insights for Fintech

To avoid running into the same problem that Synapse Inc. encountered, fintech companies are advised to undertake some proactive measures:

  • Provide clear and transparent as well as well-documented agreements with banking partners. Periodically review and update such agreements, so that new risks are addressed.  The goal is to foster positive, sustainable relationships.
  • Test and verify that middleware systems can effectively process complex financial transactions and reconciliation processes.

See:  How GenAI Is Transforming Risk and Compliance in Banking

  • Compliance. Compliance. Compliance. Adhere tightly to the specifications of the regulatory bodies to avoid major operational gotchas.
  • Establish and follow extensive risks management frameworks with contingency plans for operational breakdowns and partnership failures.

The Road Ahead

As the sector looks on amid the ruins of Synapse’s collapse, it is obvious that fintech firms and their financiers will need to re-establish trust and a high degree of operating resilience. The appointment of an unaffiliated Chapter 11 trustee will serve to manage the immediate crisis, but the fallout will be felt among BaaS participants for some time.


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - Implications of the BaaS Synapse CollapseThe National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, artificial intelligence, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

Latest news - Implications of the BaaS Synapse CollapseFF Logo 400 v3 - Implications of the BaaS Synapse Collapsecommunity social impact - Implications of the BaaS Synapse Collapse

Support NCFA by Following us on Twitter!







NCFA Sign up for our newsletter - Implications of the BaaS Synapse Collapse




 

EU: MiCA, DORA, Open Finance Framework, and Digital Euro

Regulation | May 23, 2024

Freepik EU - EU:  MiCA, DORA, Open Finance Framework, and Digital Euro

Image: Freepik

Key Digital Finance Legislation in the European Union

Digital finance in the EU refers to all financial services and instruments that rely on new Information and Communications Technology (ICT) from digital payment services and instruments to new market infrastructure for crypto assets using distributed ledger technologies. Below is an overview based on the European Parliament's briefing update on 'Digital Finance Legislation:  Overview and State of Play".  It is quite essential for the regulation and framework set upon by the EU to find a balance between innovation and digitization that will in turn provide an environment that is safe both for risk management and the consumers' protection.

2020 Digital Finance Package

Collectively, the digital finance regulations are called, "The 2020 package" and they are a foundational regulatory framework focusing on:

  1. Tackling market fragmentation
  2. Facilitating digital innovation
  3. Promoting a financial data space
  4. Addressing new digital finance challenges

See:  EU Lawmakers Approve Historic AI Regulation Act

Overall, the package aims to improve market efficiency, strengthen consumer protection and support innovation by:

  • Streamlining digital finance regulations
  • Providing clear regulatory frameworks for digital finance innovations
  • Providing a supportive regulatory environment, fostering new financial technologies

Four (4) Key Digital Finance Regulations

1. Markets in Crypto-assets Regulation (MiCA)

MiCA regulation is set out in such a way that it safeguards consumers and firms using crypto-assets and facilitates innovation.  The regulation will secure a sound and transparent legal basis for crypto-assets market, harnessing the potential of innovation while ensuring financial stability.

The above regulation is going to achieve such factors:

  • A clear and robust legal framework of DLT-based crypto-assets.
  • Enhanced protections of consumers and investors' interests, and finally
  • Ensuring market integrity and promoting innovation

Status: Enforcement since June 2023

Key Dates: Measures under Level 2 should be applicable by December 2024

2. Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA)

DORA regulation is designed to ensure the financial sector is resilient to ICT-induced disruptions and cyber-attacks.  It enhances operational resilience and cybersecurity in financial operations by requiring detailed documentation and management of risks.

DORA has the following objectives:

  • Effective ICT operation
  • Governance and control framework for ICT
  • Effective third-party risk management

Status: Enforcement by January 2023

Key Dates: The law will be applicable by 17 January 2025

3. Open Finance Framework

This is a framing of infrastructures that allow for access to financial data.  This will allow consumers and small and medium enterprises to share data securely with third-party service providers.  The legislation gives consumers control and access to their financial data, thereby enabling innovation in competitive financial services.

See:  Small Step Forward As Canada Publishs Straw-man Open Banking Framework

This framework has the following objectives:

  • Access to data for businesses and consumers from institutions without any hindrance
  • A visionary protection of data under GDPR

Status: The legislative proposal for the same was put forth in June 2021.

Key Dates: The process is at the state of being in the legislative process.

4. Digital Euro

Digital Euro is a project through which ECB seeks to acquire a form of the digital euro which they seek to supplement with what is already physical currency.  This will pave the way for modernizing the EU payment infrastructure to allow secure and efficient digital transactions.

As per the ECB, Digital Euro would serve the following purposes:

  • Reduce dependency on non-EU payment service providers
  • Adapt to the growth in digital payment trends
  • Strengthen strategic autonomy of the European Union in the financial sector

See:  Open Banking: Revolutionizing Financial Data Sharing

Status: It has the same status—legislative proposals introduced in June 2021.

Key Dates: The adoption of the legislative mandates is pending.

Conclusion

EU digital finance legislation will be a foundational building block for a secure, innovative, and competitive financial ecosystem. The regulations will enhance market efficiency, ensure consumer protection, and foster technological advancements in the financial sector.


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - EU:  MiCA, DORA, Open Finance Framework, and Digital EuroThe National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, artificial intelligence, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

Latest news - EU:  MiCA, DORA, Open Finance Framework, and Digital EuroFF Logo 400 v3 - EU:  MiCA, DORA, Open Finance Framework, and Digital Eurocommunity social impact - EU:  MiCA, DORA, Open Finance Framework, and Digital Euro

Support NCFA by Following us on Twitter!







NCFA Sign up for our newsletter - EU:  MiCA, DORA, Open Finance Framework, and Digital Euro




 

API Magic: Empowering Payment Services Providers and Fintech Innovators to Scale

DC Bank | Jeffrey J. Smith | April 24, 2024

Jeffrey J. Smith DC Bank - API Magic: Empowering Payment Services Providers and Fintech Innovators to Scale

Jeffrey J. Smith, Co-Founder, CEO & Director, DC Bank

In today's fast-paced digital world, scaling efficiently is a must-have for your business. As technology continues to reshape the financial industry, Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) are revolutionizing the game. APIs make it easy to connect systems, ensuring secure and smooth data exchange. When it comes to payment solutions, APIs are the secret sauce for businesses to scale effortlessly. At Digital Commerce Group of Companies (DC Group), we're trailblazers in digital payment solutions for financial innovators. Our API developer tools are top-notch, giving you extended functionality and full control over the services you provide. As experts in the field, we’re sharing some thoughts on how to leverage API payment technology to grow your business.

Embracing the Power of an API

API-driven solutions offer a wide range of opportunities for financial services providers and fintech entrepreneurs alike. They bring flexibility, speed, and open exciting avenues for boosting revenue. With APIs, you can easily integrate with your existing systems, allowing you to enhance your technology stack while reducing development time. This lets you focus on delivering value back to your customers, while reducing your time-to-market.

Finding a Trusted Technology Partner

When it comes to integrating payment solutions, choosing a trusted partner is key. First, look for a solid reputation, top-notch security measures, a range of cutting-edge products, and easy integration. At DC Group, our dynamic platform offers state-of-the-art APIs with advanced features that let you take control of your technology to customize the payment experience. We build adaptive programs that give fintech innovators the means to scale and pivot with ever-changing business demands.

See:  Embedded Finance: Banking Meets the Customer

Second, when scouting a potential partner, be sure to ask questions — can they handle increased transaction volumes and adapt to evolving industry standards? (Hint: we can!) You’ll also need responsive customer support to address any concerns. By choosing a reliable API partner, you can rest easy knowing your transactions are in good hands, allowing you to grow your business, and stay ahead in a competitive market. Our tech-obsessed team at DC Group works with you to uncover challenges that are holding your technology back or slowing your business down. We help dream up a solution that ensures you succeed in today's fast-paced digital landscape.

Enhancing Your Customer Experience

Whether you're a payment services provider or a fintech entrepreneur, API-driven payment solutions offer exciting possibilities to level up your customer experience and streamline operations. With APIs, you can incorporate third-party applications, giving your customers access to a diverse range of financial products all in one place. This seamless integration not only simplifies the customer experience but can also expand your product offering with a trusted interface that's sure to attract new customers.

Offering More Services

API-driven payment solutions have revolutionized the financial industry, empowering businesses to scale effortlessly. Through our best-in-class API developer tools, we work with businesses to integrate a wide range of services — from payment and E-transfer capabilities, to card services and digital wallets.

See:  FinTech’s Role in Modern Treasury Management: Streamlining Operations and Capital Optimization

We’re passionate about helping businesses build faster and level-up the services they provide. Embrace the power of APIs and propel your business into the future of finance with DC Group's comprehensive API-driven payment solutions.

About the Author

By Jeffrey J. Smith, Co-Founder, CEO & Director

Mr. Smith, the co-founder and CEO of DCBank, is a seasoned entrepreneur with over 30 years of experience in international financial services. He has an impressive track record of operating, financing, and expanding large-scale businesses. Mr. Smith has successfully sourced, negotiated, and integrated numerous acquisitions in Canada and abroad. He was recognized as the Industry Person of the Year for Prepaid & Payments by Payments eXchange in 2013 and received the Ernst & Young Entrepreneur of the Year award for the Prairies Region in 2005. Additionally, he served as a Board Member of the Interac Association from 2012 to 2017.


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - API Magic: Empowering Payment Services Providers and Fintech Innovators to ScaleThe National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, artificial intelligence, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

Latest news - API Magic: Empowering Payment Services Providers and Fintech Innovators to ScaleFF Logo 400 v3 - API Magic: Empowering Payment Services Providers and Fintech Innovators to Scalecommunity social impact - API Magic: Empowering Payment Services Providers and Fintech Innovators to Scale

Support NCFA by Following us on Twitter!







NCFA Sign up for our newsletter - API Magic: Empowering Payment Services Providers and Fintech Innovators to Scale




 

The Transition Towards Open Finance in the UK

Open Finance | April 19, 2024

Innovate Finance and KPMG Roadmap to Open Finance in the UK - The Transition Towards Open Finance in the UK

Image: Innovate Finance and KPMG, The Roadmap to Open Finance in the UK (cover)

Balancing Innovation and Privacy in the UK's Open Finance Evolution

As the UK steadily advances towards the implementation of Open Finance, a delicate balance is being sought between pioneering financial services and the imperative protection of individual privacy. Drawing insights from the KPMG report "The Roadmap to Open Finance in the UK," this article examines the transformative potential of extending Open Banking principles to a wider financial landscape. While Open Finance promises to enhance accessibility and efficiency across financial services, concerns about privacy and increased surveillance present significant challenges.

How Open Finance Differs from Open Banking

Open Finance refers to the extension of Open Banking data-sharing principles to a wider range of financial products beyond just banking, such as investments, pensions, and insurance. It allows third-party providers to access financial data across different sectors, provided they have the consumer’s consent. This broader scope aims to create a more integrated, transparent financial services environment where consumers have better control over their financial data and can benefit from personalized financial products.

See:  BoE Report: Open Banking Boosts Productivity, Competition

While Open Banking focuses primarily on banking data, allowing third-party applications to access bank account information to provide consolidated views and innovative services, Open Finance extends this to virtually all aspects of a person's financial life. Open Finance seeks to create a holistic view of a person's financial situation, leading to more tailored advice, better financial planning, and easier management of personal finances across different platforms.

Building Blocks for Open Finance

These components collectively enable a secure and consumer-centric Open Finance ecosystem. Regulatory frameworks and standardized protocols ensure that all parties follow a uniform approach to data handling and sharing, which simplifies integration and cooperation. Security measures protect data integrity and build consumer trust, which is pivotal for the acceptance and success of Open Finance.

See:  Small Step Forward As Feds Publish Straw-man Open Banking Framework

Consumer consent management empowers users, ensuring they remain in control of their data and who accesses it. The technological infrastructure supports the actual delivery of services, ensuring that the system is both resilient and scalable. Lastly, stakeholder collaboration ensures that the system is comprehensive and benefits all parties involved.

  • Comprehensive regulatory frameworks ensure that all participants in the Open Finance environment adhere to strict guidelines regarding data sharing, privacy, and security. This includes updates to existing financial laws and the introduction of new policies tailored to the complexities of managing multi-dimensional financial data across different sectors.
  • To facilitate seamless data sharing, standardized protocols are essential. These protocols define how data is exchanged between different financial entities, ensuring that systems are interoperable and can communicate without friction.
  • Advanced and robust security protocols such as encryption, secure APIs (Application Programming Interfaces), and authentication mechanisms are necessary to protect sensitive financial data against breaches and unauthorized access.
  • A central component of Open Finance is the empowerment of consumers to control who can access their data. This requires a transparent mechanism for consumers to grant and revoke consent as needed, ideally through an easy-to-use interface that provides clear options.

See:  CIBC Partners with U.S. Fintech to Enable Open Banking API

  • IT infrastructure to support the high volumes of data exchanges and the complex processing required to deliver personalized financial services. This includes cloud services, data centers, and support systems to handle the load and provide uptime guarantees.
  • Open Finance requires the active participation of banks, fintechs, insurance companies, investment firms, and other financial services providers. Holistic stakeholder collaboration is crucial to ensure the ecosystem is inclusive, catering to all aspects of consumer and business finances.

A Day in the Life Examples

These scenarios demonstrate how Open Finance can streamline financial management, making it more integrated, intuitive, and responsive to the needs of consumers and businesses alike, marking a significant evolution from traditional financial services.

See:  Canada’s Open Banking Journey: Interview with Brenton Charnley, CEO and Founder of Open Finance Advisors, Australia (Ex-TrueLayer ANZ CEO)

Consumer

Imagine Sarah, a freelance graphic designer. With Open Finance, she starts her day by checking a financial dashboard app that integrates data from her bank accounts, investment portfolios, and freelance income management tools. She reviews her monthly budget, which is automatically adjusted based on her recent spending and earnings. The app suggests ways to optimize her savings and alerts her about better mortgage rates, thanks to a comprehensive view of her financial health. She approves a switch to a new insurance provider offering a better rate, all within the same app, secured by her biometric authentication.

Small Business

Consider a small business, 'Bloom Coffee Roasters.' The owner, Tom, uses an Open Finance-enabled platform to manage the business's finances. He reviews real-time data on his supply chain financing, business loans, and cash flow all from a single interface. The system uses AI to forecast cash flow for the next quarter and suggests applying for a short-term loan to cover a predicted shortfall. Tom can compare loan offers from multiple providers directly through the platform and secure financing quickly, without needing to provide extensive documentation, as lenders already have access to the necessary data through Open Finance protocols.

Privacy and Surveillance Concerns

Open Finance represents a significant shift in how financial data is accessed and shared, bringing with it immense benefits such as enhanced financial services, better personal finance management, and increased market competitiveness. However, the adoption of Open Finance in the UK, or any region for that matter, is not without its complexities, particularly concerning privacy and surveillance.

See:  Embedded Finance: Banking Meets the Customer

Privacy concerns are paramount, as Open Finance by its very nature involves the sharing of sensitive personal and business financial information across a broad array of platforms and institutions. The apprehension that this data might be misused, or that it could increase the risk of surveillance by government entities, is a significant concern for many. These fears are not unfounded, given the increasing capabilities of technology and the interest of governments in monitoring financial flows to combat fraud, money laundering, and tax evasion.

Is Open Finance a Near Reality or a Distant Vision?

In the immediate future, the UK is likely to see incremental advances towards Open Finance. The groundwork laid by Open Banking, which has already been implemented with a fair degree of success, provides a foundational framework. However, extending this to a broader Open Finance framework will require not only technological and regulatory adjustments but also a significant cultural shift among consumers and institutions regarding data sharing.  Ultimately, Open Finance is envisioned as a fully integrated system that could revolutionize financial services. Achieving this vision will involve overcoming not just technical and regulatory challenges, but also building public trust and ensuring robust privacy protections are in place.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while Open Finance in the UK holds the promise of transforming the financial services sector, its full realization as a ubiquitous system remains a longer-term goal. Immediate future developments are likely to be gradual, focusing on building the necessary infrastructure, regulatory frameworks, and public trust.

See:  Canadian Loyalty to Financial Institution Reveal ‘Soft Satisfaction’ 62% Open to Change

Given the complexities and potential resistance due to privacy concerns, it is realistic to view Open Finance as a long-term vision with real hurdles to overcome. Time will tell.  However, like most 'new things' in life, with careful planning and commitment to privacy and consumer rights, these challenges can be overcome.


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - The Transition Towards Open Finance in the UKThe National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, artificial intelligence, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

Latest news - The Transition Towards Open Finance in the UKFF Logo 400 v3 - The Transition Towards Open Finance in the UKcommunity social impact - The Transition Towards Open Finance in the UK

Support NCFA by Following us on Twitter!







NCFA Sign up for our newsletter - The Transition Towards Open Finance in the UK




 

Small Step Forward As Feds Publish Straw-man Open Banking Framework

Consumer-Driven Banking | April 17, 2024

Freepik Budget - Small Step Forward As Feds Publish Straw-man Open Banking Framework

Image: Freepik

2024 Budget Announces Next Steps on Canada's Consumer-Driven Banking Framework But Lacks Clarity on Launch Date

The 2024 federal budget announcement of Canada's Consumer-Driven Banking Framework takes another step towards implementing a 'made in Canada' Open Banking regime with a strong emphasis on security and consumer rights. Although the framework lacks a definitive launch date that adds a shadow of uncertainty over its practical rollout. This lack of clarity raises questions about the capacity to keep up with global digital finance initiatives with the aim of delivering timely benefits to Canadian consumers and businesses.

See:  Canada’s Open Banking Framework 2024 Preview

Key Announcements

The key announcements made in Canada's 2024 Consumer-Driven Banking Framework as outlined in the federal budget document include several important elements aimed at establishing and guiding the implementation of open banking in Canada:

  • Legislative Timeline --> The government plans to introduce two key pieces of legislation, one in the spring and another in the fall of 2024, to lay down the regulatory and operational groundwork for open banking.
  • Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) Oversight --> The FCAC has been designated as the primary regulatory body for overseeing the open banking framework. This includes enhanced responsibilities and the establishment of a new Deputy Commissioner for Open Banking to provide managerial oversight.
  • Funding Allocations --> The framework includes specific budgetary allocations for the preparatory and oversight work related to open banking:
    • $1 million to the FCAC to help prepare the regulatory environment for open banking.
    • $4.1 million up to 2026-2027 is being allocated to the Department of Finance (itself) for policy work on open banking. This funding is intended to support the development and refinement of policies governing the open banking ecosystem.

See:   Open Banking: Revolutionizing Financial Data Sharing

  • A formal review of the Consumer-Driven Banking Framework is scheduled to take place three years after the initial implementation, no earlier than 2027. This review will assess the effectiveness of the framework and make necessary adjustments based on the operational experiences and emerging technological and market developments.
  • The introduction of a structured accreditation process for financial institutions and fintech companies wishing to participate in open banking. This process aims to ensure that all entities meet stringent security and operational standards.
  • Commitment to the development of a unified technical standard for data sharing across the financial sector to ensure compatibility, security, and efficiency in the exchange of consumer data between banks and third-party providers.
  • The framework emphasizes the importance of robust consumer protection measures, including clear consent mechanisms, privacy safeguards, and rights to data portability. These measures are designed to empower consumers while ensuring their financial data is handled securely and responsibly.

These announcements collectively outline the Canadian government’s strategic approach to implementing a secure and consumer-focused open banking system that aligns with international best practices and addresses the specific needs of Canadian consumers and the financial services market.

Now a Few Questions and Concerns

  • Implementation and oversight timeline -->"The government will review Canada’s Consumer-Driven Banking Framework after three years”.  Our interpretation is that implementation will happen within 3 years, with a post-implementation review happening after 3 years. So, technically the review will happen no earlier than 2027, and there are 'no guarantees or specific launch date' which is concerning given the track record and could be interpreted 'small step forward with exit ramps'. Even proceeding in 2027 puts Canada ten years behind Great Britain and eight years behind Australia and four behind the U.S. Not great for consumers; not great for small businesses.
  • The framework includes a formal accreditation process for entities wishing to participate. This is crucial for ensuring that only qualified entities handle sensitive financial data. However, the rigidity and complexity of this process could potentially limit the number and diversity of participants, especially smaller fintechs that may not have the resources to meet stringent requirements. This could stifle innovation compared to more flexible systems in other countries.

See:  Open Banking Insights: Decoding Canada’s Financial Future

  • The expansion of the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada's (FCAC) mandate to include oversight of consumer-driven banking adds an additional layer of regulatory scrutiny. While this enhances consumer protection, it also introduces more bureaucracy and complexity given the scope and demands, which could slow down the pace of innovation and adaptation within the sector, especially when compared to regions with less stringent oversight.
  • The framework grants significant powers to the Minister of Finance, including the ability to refuse, suspend, or revoke access to the framework for national security-related reasons. Not a bad idea but this broad authority could be seen as introducing a level of political influence or discretion that might not be as pronounced in other jurisdictions. It could raise concerns about transparency and fairness in how these powers are exercised.
  • The decision to use a single technical standard for data sharing is intended to promote security and interoperability. However, this approach can also be seen as restrictive, potentially limiting the framework's ability to adapt to new technologies or integrate with systems that might use different standards. This contrasts with more flexible approaches seen in other countries that may allow for multiple standards or more adaptive technical frameworks.
    • Under the PSD2 (Payment Services Directive 2), the EU does not mandate a single data sharing standard across all member states. Instead, it sets the regulatory framework and allows different technical standards to develop. This has led to a variety of API (Application Programming Interface) standards emerging, such as the Berlin Group's NextGenPSD2 framework, STET, and others used by different banking groups across the continent.
    • The US does not have a formal regulatory framework for open banking mandated by the government but is working on it:  Open Banking Regulation in the U.S. Strikes a Chord. Instead, data sharing standards are largely driven by market forces and agreements between individual banks and fintech companies. This has resulted in a diversity of data sharing standards and protocols, including those developed by financial data aggregators and fintechs under frameworks like the Financial Data Exchange (FDX) and the earlier Open Financial Exchange (OFX).
    • Although the UK initially implemented a single standard for open banking under the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) order, it has seen broader data sharing initiatives that are not strictly limited to the open banking APIs. These include broader financial data sharing under frameworks like Open Finance, which contemplate a wider range of financial products and services beyond just banking.
    • While the Consumer Data Right (CDR) in Australia started with open banking and has a primary standard, it is designed to be extended to other sectors (like energy and telecommunications) and allows for the development and endorsement of additional standards over time as the system evolves and as new sectors are brought under the CDR regime.

Outlook

Ultimately, while the framework for Consumer-Driven Banking in Canada lays a solid foundation for enhanced consumer protection and streamlined financial data sharing, its real success will hinge on the execution speed and adaptability of its policies. The framework's potential risks and slow implementation could impede progress, leaving Canada trailing behind its international peers in financial innovation. Moving forward, it will be crucial for policymakers to refine and expedite the framework's application, ensuring that it not only matches global standards but also actively promotes a competitive and innovative financial environment.


Learn More from NCFA Canada's thought leadership series titled "Canada’s Open Banking Journey"

Expert interviews and insights focused on establishing a made-in-Canada open banking regime. The series aims to contribute to shaping a system that will significantly change how financial services are created, distributed, and consumed in Canada over the coming decades.


Select Episodes

1. The Foundations of Open Banking

Jul 15, 2021:  Interview with Simon Redfern, Founder of the Open Bank (Germany)

Episode: Explore the origins and impact of open banking standards globally with Simon Redfern. Learn how these frameworks can drive innovation and transparency in financial services. More

2. A Global Bank's Perspective

Sep 20, 2021:  Interview with Carmela Gomez Castelao and Jose Luis Navarro Llorens, BBVA (Spain)

Episode:  Discover BBVA's strategic approach to open banking across its global operations, highlighting the balance between innovation and customer security. More

3. The API Ecosystem

Dec 1, 2021:  Interview with Huw Davies, Ozone API (UK)

Episode: Huw Davies explains the importance of robust API standards for fostering a secure and interoperable open banking ecosystem. More

4. Consumer-Centric Financial Solutions

Jan 15, 2022:  Interview with Søren Nielsen, Subaio (Denmark)

Episode: Søren Nielsen shares how Danish fintech Subaio focuses on consumer empowerment through open banking, enhancing financial management tools. More

5. Fintech Integration and Innovation

Mar 22, 2022:  Interview with Abe Karar, Fintech Galaxy (UAE)

Episode: Explore the integration of open banking with fintech ecosystems, highlighting innovations and new product development. More


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - Small Step Forward As Feds Publish Straw-man Open Banking FrameworkThe National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, artificial intelligence, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

Latest news - Small Step Forward As Feds Publish Straw-man Open Banking FrameworkFF Logo 400 v3 - Small Step Forward As Feds Publish Straw-man Open Banking Frameworkcommunity social impact - Small Step Forward As Feds Publish Straw-man Open Banking Framework

Support NCFA by Following us on Twitter!







NCFA Sign up for our newsletter - Small Step Forward As Feds Publish Straw-man Open Banking Framework