Exploring cryptoasset regulation

Investment Executive | James Langton | Oct 12, 2018

cryptoassets - Exploring cryptoasset regulationMoney laundering and tax evasion are key concerns

Canadian policy-makers initially took a hands-off approach to cryptoassets. Now, in the wake of a bitcoin boom-and-bust and continuing growth in the cryptoassets market, policy-makers are taking a second look at the emerging phenomenon.

In 2015, the Standing Senate Committee on Banking, Trade and Commerce issued one of Canada’s first reports examining the emerging cryptocurrency industry; that report recommends that policy-makers keep an eye on the space.

Since then, the cryptoassets market has continued to grow. According to a report from the Bank of Canada (BoC), the global market capitalization for cryptoassets “grew rapidly” in 2017 and the daily transaction volume now is more than 75 times higher than it was in early 2017 – i.e., more than $25 billion a day.

At this point, the BoC report states, traditional financial services institutions don’t have much, if any, direct exposure to cryptoassets, but the report cautions that these institutions could become exposed due to their clients’ trading in cryptoassets or through exchange trading in crypto-based derivatives.

“Cryptoasset markets are evolving quickly and could have financial stability implications in the future if their size and links to the financial system continue to grow,” the BoC report states. “The markets are largely unregulated in many countries and are characterized by high price volatility, fragile liquidity, and frequent fraud and cyberattacks.”

See:  International Anti-Money Laundering Standards for Crypto Expected in October

The Senate committee’s original report in 2015 acknowledged risks, such as money laundering and tax evasion, that could accompany widespread use of cryptocurrencies. The report also recognized that a heavy-handed approach to regulation could stifle innovation and lead to missed opportunities – opportunities resulting from the development of the underlying financial technology that enables the creation of cryptocurrencies (via blockchain [a.k.a. distributed ledger] technology) and improves inclusion and enhances the efficiency and security of cryptocurrencies in financial transactions.

Now, as the cryptoassets market continues to flourish, the Senate committee is revisiting the subject. However, the committee has had its financial services sector expertise bolstered since its initial report with the addition of Howard Wetston, former chairman of the Ontario Securities Commission, and Sabi Marwah, former vice chairman and chief operating officer at Bank of Nova Scotia.

The Senate committee began questioning federal Finance Minister Bill Morneau in late September about the current condition of the cryptoassets market and its evolution in the three years since the committee issued its recommendations as part of its overall mandate to review the state of the financial services system.

During that hearing, Morneau said that because the cryptoasset phenomenon is global in nature, the policy response must be co-ordinated at the global level: “The world’s financial systems are highly integrated and it’s easy for sophisticated users of cryptoassets to adapt their practices – for initial coin offerings or subsequent exchanges – to avoid regulation.”

However, a report from the Financial Stability Board (FSB), a global umbrella group for fi- nancial services sector policy- makers, concluded in July that at this point, the cryptoassets market is too small to represent any systemic risk to the global financial services system.

See:  Don Tapscott urges ‘sensible’ cryptocurrency regulations

According to the BoC’s report, the total worldwide market value of all cryptoassets peaked at more than $1 trillion at the beginning of 2018. In contrast, the market capitalization of global equities markets was more than $75 trillion. Notably, the market value of cryptoassets has fallen substantially since that peak.

Given the FSB’s report’s conclusion, Morneau noted, most countries (including Canada) still are taking a restrained approach to regulation. They remain wary of suppressing innovation by cracking down too hard on the industry, but also now are beginning to erect defences due to long-standing concerns about tax evasion and money laundering.

Indeed, Morneau indicated that money laundering has emerged as the central concern for global policy-makers in regard to cryptoassets.

“We have had this discussion literally every time the G7 finance ministers and central bank governors get together,” Morneau told the Senate committee. “The focus has been on trying to find ways we can work together because this is an area [in which] we have no choice but to work together.”

Later this month, the global intergovernmental Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering (FATF) is expected to issue guidance that would establish how its regulatory standards for fighting money laundering and terrorist financing should be applied in the cryptoassets industry.

“This is a significant step forward,” Morneau said, noting that this step will mean the FATF is going beyond simply monitoring the issues, and taking action.

Over the summer, the Department of Finance Canada launched a consultation on proposed changes to Canada’s anti-money laundering (AML) rules that aim to capture dealers of cryptoassets and virtual currencies under the existing framework for monitoring financial transactions in Canada.

When those changes take effect, financial services firms will be required to register with the Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada (FINTRAC) and develop compliance strategies for detecting and reporting suspicious transactions.

At the same time, the revised AML regulations aim to define “cryptoassets” and draw a line between these investment instruments and traditional currencies.  “This approach will improve regulatory certainty surrounding cryptoassets without regulating the underlying technology, in keeping with our goal of mitigating risk without stifling innovation,” Morneau said.

Yet, the Senate committee questioned if extending FINTRAC rules to the cryptoassets space is enough. Marwah noted that cryptoassets are designed to evade regulation. He also wonders whether simply applying the AML requirements from the traditional financial system to the emerging cryptoassets markets is adequate. He questioned whether Canada should require that cryptoassets be traded on securities exchanges, where those investment instruments can be more easily monitored.

See:  CIBC Has Frozen $28 Million of Vancouver Crypto Exchange’s Funds Since January

During the Senate hearing, Rob Stewart, associate deputy minister of finance and G7/G20 deputy for Canada, indicated that there are ongoing discussions among Finance Canada, the BoC and the provincial securities regulators about tracking cryptoasset trading activity.

“At this point, the judgment has not been that we need to, collectively or at an individual level, tighten the rules further than we have currently proposed to do in the AML rules,” Stewart said.

Wetston told the hearing that there appears to be an appetite for regulation among firms establishing the cryptoassets market: “My discussion with some of the digital currency firms suggests they want a framework. They want to function in a legitimate environment.”

Wetston also noted the global financial crisis highlighted the risks in allowing certain financial activities to grow unchecked: “I implore you to think about our experiences in the past and avoid the delay that’s necessary to put this framework in place [to] ensure these businesses can function on a platform and have the regulatory audit, tracking, tracing and transparency necessary.”

Stewart believes the cryptoassets market is receiving “greater scrutiny” as a result of the financial crisis. But, he said, the industry is not considered significant enough to warrant a major effort to regulate the space tightly: “The judgment call at this point in time is that the scale of the activity at a market level has not come anywhere near the scale of the activity of derivatives or asset-backed commercial paper.”

Thus, policy-makers aren’t yet prepared to impose an overarching regulatory framework on the cryptoassets industry.

“We are enhancing consumer protections and disclosure,” Stewart noted, adding that securities regulators are focusing on investor protection and federal authorities are targeting the money laundering concern.

The Standing Senate Committee on Banking, Trade and Commerce plans to study the concept of “open banking,” which is an approach to enhancing competition in the financial services sector that the federal government also is set to explore.

Continue to the full article --> here


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - Exploring cryptoasset regulation The National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

Latest news - Exploring cryptoasset regulationFF Logo 400 v3 - Exploring cryptoasset regulationcommunity social impact - Exploring cryptoasset regulation
NCFA Summer Kickoff Event Jul 11 banner resize - Exploring cryptoasset regulation

Yahoo Finance | VeChain Release | June 25, 2019 BEIJING, June 25, 2019 /PRNewswire/ -- On June 25, in combination with Walmart China, China Chain-Store & Franchise Association (CCFA), PwC, Inner Mongolia Kerchin Co., Ltd., and VeChain, the Walmart China Blockchain Traceability Platform, built on the VeChainThor Blockchain, was announced at the 2019 China Products Safety Publicity Week Traceability System Construction Seminar. This seminar was jointly organized by Walmart China and the CCFA in Beijing. The announcement of the Walmart China Blockchain Traceability Platform came with the introduction to the first batch of 23 product lines that have been tested and launched on the Platform. The Platform is expected to scale by another 100 product lines by the end of the year covering more than 10 product categories including fresh meat product, rice, mushrooms, cooking oil, etc. It is expected that the Walmart China's  traceability system will see traceable fresh meat account for 50% of the total sales of packaged fresh meat, traceable vegetables will account for 40% of the total sales of packaged vegetables, traceable seafood will account for 12.5% of the total sales of seafood by the end of 2020. See:  Q&A: Walmart’s Frank Yiannas on the use ...
Read More
walmart and vechain food safety - Exploring cryptoasset regulation
Crowdfund Insider | JD Alois | June 20, 2019 The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has published a statutory report on Regulation Crowdfunding commonly referenced as Reg CF. The mandated report must be forwarded to Congress three years after Reg CF rules became effective (May 2016). Reg CF is the smallest of three federal “crowdfunding” exemptions allowing issuers to raise just $1.07 million from both accredited and non-accredited investors. According to the report authors: “the number of crowdfunding offerings, as well as the total amount of funding during the considered period, was relatively modest.” The report tallies activity under Reg CF from May 2016 to December 31, 2018. At the end of the period, there were 45 active Portals and 9 Broker-Dealers which had participated in at least one Reg CF offering. See: $5 million Equity crowdfunding extended to private companies Early-stage Investing – The Public gets a Seat at the Table Three platforms accounted for two-thirds of all initiated offerings and proceeds raised. SEC: the number of #RegCF #crowdfunding offerings, as well as the total amount of funding during the considered period, was relatively modest Click to Tweet According to the SEC: Between May 16, 2016, and December 31, ...
Read More
RegCF SEC report - Exploring cryptoasset regulation
Chambers Pivot Industries | Greg Chambers | June 20, 2019 "All I need is an investor, and I’m ready to go," she says. I'm sitting in front of a passionate entrepreneur who knows I've successfully raised millions of dollars for various businesses. After hearing her story, what I'm about to say won't be what she wants to hear, but it's true. Funding isn't her problem. There's more money out looking for a home than there are good ideas to fund. The problem, I tell her, is she hasn't decided if she wants to build a company or master the growing seed and startup capital environment. Lessons from the past I was in her seat in the late 1990s shopping my big idea from investor to investor. Eventually unsuccessful, I was forced to abandon my startup and find a job. I took two big lessons from that experience. One is that if I wanted to get a company off the ground, I needed to get much better at selling a vision to investors. Second, based on the questions the investors were asking, I needed far more evidence from customers that my idea was the right one before they’d invest. Years later, ...
Read More
hunter to prey - Exploring cryptoasset regulation
Luge Capital | Karim Gillani | June 2019 Intro:  NCFA Fintech Confidential spoke with some of Canada’s experienced fintech investors, on their background, how Canada has evolved, what we should be doing, advice to fintech founders and what keeps them awake at night.  This is part 1 of a 4 part series.   What is your background, and how did you come to co-found Luge Capital? Karim:  My background is in fintech, mobile tech, engineering, finance and strategy. Prior to Luge, I was at PayPal, leading M&A activities in Canada. I joined PayPal through its $890M acquisition of Xoom, a renowned cross-border remittance company, where I started the Corporate Development practice. I have an Engineering degree from the University of Waterloo, a Master of Finance degree from the University of London and a Master of Laws from the University of Toronto. Luge Capital was the byproduct of highly motivated LPs, and a recognition that fintech venture capital needed a kickstart at the early stages. David Nault and I co-founded Luge in early 2018 with a new model to seek out entrepreneurs in the US and Canada that not only had a drive to take over the world, but also built their ...
Read More
luge capital - Exploring cryptoasset regulation
CDL Team | June 18, 2019 The Libra Association announces a new initiative with the goal of increasing access to financial services and fostering financial inclusion around the world TORONTO, CANADA – Today, Creative Destruction Lab (CDL) – a not-for-profit seed-stage startup program – announces that it will be a Founding Partner of the Libra Association. CDL is keen to contribute to the success of the Libra initiative as the sole Canadian organization and academic institution in the Libra Association at present. The Libra Association will create Libra, a simple global currency and financial infrastructure that can empower billions of people. Libra will be built on a secure, scalable, and reliable blockchain; and it will be backed by a reserve of assets designed to give it intrinsic value. The Libra Association will govern the infrastructure and manage and evolve this new ecosystem. Libra will enable developers and businesses to build inclusive new financial service products for people around the world. See:  Facebook’s Libra Cryptocurrency: Everything We Know At this time, CDL is the sole academic Founding Partner of the Libra Association. The initial group of organizations that will work together on finalizing the association’s charter include: Payments: Mastercard, PayPal, PayU ...
Read More
CDL libra - Exploring cryptoasset regulation
PC Mag | Rob Marvin | June 18, 2019 Facebook's Libra Cryptocurrency: Everything We Know Facebook's big blockchain play, consisting of the Libra coin, the nonprofit Libra Foundation, and Facebook's Calibra wallet, will create a crypto-based payments ecosystem across Facebook, Messenger, WhatsApp, and beyond. Facebook's long-rumored cryptocurrency finally got its big debut, and it's called Libra after all. Facebook today released a lengthy white paper, along with a post from Mark Zuckerberg and another from VP of blockchain David Marcus, announcing the ambitious crypto initiative and all that comes with it. The open-source Libra cryptocurrency and blockchain will be governed by the nonprofit Libra Association, while a new Facebook-owned subsidiary called Calibra will release a wallet for Libra tokens and ultimately other banking and finance products—a move that could turn Facebook into a financial services giant in addition to a social and advertising one. See:  Facebook’s Cryptocurrency: Great Idea, Wrong Company While the public launch of Libra won't happen until the first half of 2020, the developer testnet of the Libra blockchain is live today. There will also be a new programming language called Move for developers to build distributed applications atop the Libra blockchain, though Facebook said neither itself ...
Read More
facebook launches libra - Exploring cryptoasset regulation
3iQ and Mavennet | Fred Pye and Kesem Frank | June 18, 2019 Stablecoins are now a necessary step to mass adoption of cryptocurrencies, as proven by the way they’ve been used to hedge the massive volatility of the market over the past couple of years. Their simple premise enables the seamless pairing of crypto-to-fiat pegged cryptocurrency. It might sound overly simplistic, but this straightforward innovation has spurred the growth of a new crypto asset class that measures in billions of dollars in aggregate market cap (e.g. Tether, USD Coin, TrueUSD, Paxos and Gemini Dollar). As much as this asset class is still gaining momentum driven by the current and common use case, the potential of stablecoins goes well beyond the tactical value of a trading tool. Stablecoins are strategically important because they represent a bridge between legacy fiat-based systems and the new digital and decentralized currency underpinnings we collectively call “blockchain.” The dream isn’t necessarily a prediction or extension of the purist’s vision   Bitcoin - blockchain’s earliest network - was born from tumultuous years in the traditional financial system. These were years defined by mistrust; not just towards the people at the helm of the financial system, but ...
Read More
stablecoins  - Exploring cryptoasset regulation
CNBC | Kate Rooney and Hugh Son | June 10, 2019 Mobility giant Uber is looking to accelerate the creation of financial products with a new fintech outpost in New York, according to people with knowledge of the plan. The ride-hailing company is aiming to hire several dozen engineers and product managers this year, and the New York team could eventually exceed 100 workers, said the people, who declined to be identified speaking about Uber’s plans. Uber, fresh from its IPO last month, is looking to tap New York’s talent pool, which is deeper when it comes to fintech and bank workers than its hometown of San Francisco. By building out its financial ecosystem, the company can increase its lead over rivals like Lyft. The efforts are likely to be focused on ways to increase engagement and loyalty to the Uber platform, according to people who attended a recruitment event earlier this year. Payments chief Peter Hazlehurst and top engineer Johnie Lee spoke at the event, held at Uber’s New York offices, the people said. There are many possible payment and lending innovations Uber could come up with: It has 93 million active users globally, most of whom use linked ...
Read More
Dara Khosrowshahi CEO uber tech - Exploring cryptoasset regulation
Schulte Research | Paul Schulte | June 17, 2019 Digital banking finally arrives in HK --all in one go! Be careful what you wish for — you might get it.  Hong Kong People have been kvetching for years about the poor quality of banking services. Now, they will have a deluge of ultra-efficient and essentially free new services. These services will offer strictly online banking services without branches and ALL of them have very deep pockets. The first batch below, which I will enumerate in a moment, have capital to burn of about USD 250 million. This can go a long way in eroding the highly profitable cartel of HSBC and Hang Seng Bank.  Hang Seng Bank has consistently had among the highest ROE globally north of 20-21%. And its revenue per customer has been among the world’s highest as well. HSBC owns more than 40% of HSB, so it has been a cash cow for the bank. Hong Kong is really the center of profitability for HSBC, since its ROE for commonwealth countries is the single digits and it has basically given up on the US financial market.  It’s European business, like all Euro banking franchises, is in the ...
Read More
global network and points of presence maps - Exploring cryptoasset regulation
Forbes | Enrique Dans | June 17, 2019 All the signs are that Facebook is about to launch its cryptocurrency on June 18, a project known internally as Libra, and that soon, apparently, we will all be using. So what are the implications of a company with 2.4 billion users launching its own currency? Strategically, the movement makes sense for Facebook: at a time when many question the its dominance of social networks and when a majority of its own shareholders say they want to see the back of Mark Zuckerberg, the company announces a very ambitious project of universal appeal giving it a central role in the world economy, in the wake of innumerable cryptocurrency projects of dubious legality, irresponsibly speculative and wasteful in terms of energy, aimed among others at people in countries with unstable currencies or limited banking penetration. As Jack Dorsey has said, this maybe the perfect moment to create a universal currency for the Internet era, reflecting the trend toward a universalization of the world. However, what is less clear is whether this currency should be in the hands of Facebook. See:  FaceCoin: Here’s What Facebook Could Build In Blockchain And Cryptocurrency Technically, the project ...
Read More
mark Z. facebook - Exploring cryptoasset regulation