March 1, 2019: NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden

share save 171 16 - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden

NCFA Canada | Burden Reduction Committee | March 1, 2019

burden reduction - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory BurdenExecutive Summary

In response to the Ontario Securities Commission’s (OSC’s) January 14, 2019 request for comments, this submission responds to the eight questions set out in the OSC’s Staff Notice 11-784. This submission draws heavily on, and also updates, the Association’s earlier submission to the OSC dated August 24, 2017 (see Appendix), which primarily focused on the crowdfunding requirements in Ontario.

The National Crowdfunding and Fintech Association of Canada (the Association) represents over 2,000 fintech SMEs and individual members that support financial and capital market innovation, small businesses and technology. We are pleased that the Ontario government is undertaking this important regulatory burden reduction initiative to the benefit of all Ontarians.

The Association has consulted a number of diverse crowdfunding and fintech stakeholders – including exempt market dealers, industry experts, securities lawyers, regulators and government agencies and is proposing several recommendations to reduce unjustifiable burdens placed on Ontario’s businesses.

The Association recommends that the province undertake the following:

  • The OSC conduct a review and publish a report evaluating the effectiveness of Ontario’s crowdfunding regulations (45-108) compared to other jurisdictions in Canada and international competitors such as the UK, US and Australia, including a comparison of the relative cost of capital;
  • The OSC continue its recently announced work to harmonize the crowdfunding regime across Canada (CSA Staff Notice 45-324) but do so with the goal of reducing unjustified regulatory burden and establishing harmonized regulation that make sense for the sector. In particular, all jurisdictions should review B.C.’s crowdfunding regime and consider either adopting a similar approach in harmonization;
  • Modify existing requirements so that they are principles based – detailed or prescriptive controls should only be imposed when clearly justified (ie. controls that can be quantified) and harmonized;
  • Implement specific burden reduction amendments to crowdfunding regulations:
    − Increase the 12 month issuer cap to $5 million or higher (from $1.5 million);
    − Increase the 12 month investor caps to $10k (from $2.5k) and allow accredited investors to fully participate;
    − Allow advertising and general solicitation on social media for all crowdfunding;
    − Eliminate requirements for financial statements unless raising more than $1.5 million; and
    − Allow fintech solution to streamline KYC and suitability tests.

See:  NCFA: Canada Needs a Harmonized Securities Environment as Current Provincial Approach is a Fintech Innovation Killer

Implementing these recommendations will help drive entrepreneurship, innovation and job growth.

Benefits to Ontario include:

  • Increased capital investment in the province and increased economic growth;
  • Increased investment options for investors that support small businesses across all of Ontario;
  • Crowdfunding sources remain in Canada;
  • More capital and improved access to capital specifically for small businesses, rural businesses, economically-challenged sectors, and underserviced groups (ie. women or Indigenous business owners);
  • Encourages liquidity and transparency in the markets;
  • Improved probability of retaining high growth companies in Ontario; and
  • Accelerated commercialization of new products and services.

Crowdfunding drives innovation, economic activity and job growth. It fills a critical early stage funding gap (commonly referred to as the ‘valley of death’), enables more productive investment in venture markets and strengthens early stage capital markets. Crowdlending also provides support to more mature companies looking to access capital that may fall outside the parameters of bank lending.

Background and Context

Contrary to the intent of the crowdfunding exemption, Ontario’s crowdfunding requirements hinder access to capital for SMEs across a multitude of sectors. These requirements have also restricted innovative opportunities for retail investors and our members feel the impact of this directly. Ontario’s economic growth is being hindered by regulation like the crowdfunding requirements that fails to promote economic growth. The potential of opening up regulation is significant increase in job creation and economic development. For example, Ontario’s 417,000 small businesses would benefit from the increased access to capital that crowdlending offers and the effects would be a strong boost in job creation throughout the province.

Canada has fallen behind international competitors like the U.K. and the U.S. Crowdfunding platforms now represent the largest investments at the seed stage in the U.K. and peer-to-peer platforms now represent 15% of all new bank lending to small businesses.

See: 

Ontario’s Fintech startups, small business innovators and entrepreneurs operate in a highly prescriptive, complex and costly regulatory environment:

“The Crowdfunding Exemption introduced by the [OSC] in January 2016 turned out to be much too onerous for young companies… Ontarians are locked out of equity crowdfunding and Canadian companies are restricted from accessing capital. … Unfortunately, we had to disappoint over 100 start-ups in Canada that wanted to raise capital from their supporters in Ontario.” – FrontFundr, Ontario Exempt Market Dealer

“It's extremely complex and it can be very discouraging for a lot of small entrepreneurs. There are numerous examples where in Ontario we [are] really pushing talent away or setting them up for failure because of the red tape, and the burden is huge. It is hard [enough] to start a business. You know the wages are very expensive, the rents... The regulation and the burden [is] just the complete killer.” – Anonymous NCFA member

“As a small firm, we have very tight budgets. Our compliance team has asked that we dig up very detailed and ‘historic’ information on emails, social media ads, and related campaigns. We had to devote 2 full time individuals over several months. Check-ins and site visits to confirm the material presented in the compliance report and to assist registrants in fulfilling their obligations would be far more productive. The former (exhaustive reviews) take an incredible amount of resources for both regulator and registrant and are not cost-effective.” – Anonymous NCFA member

Without a streamlined, flexible, nimble, and principles-based regulatory system – one that allows new rules to be formulated, while expelling old, outdated rules – Ontario’s regulatory climate will continue to stifle innovation and drive business costs up and productivity down. Ontario’s economy, businesses and consumers at all levels suffer, however, small businesses, innovators and entrepreneurs are the hardest hit.

“Ontario’s crowdfunding requirements have choked off access to capital for SME's across a multitude of sectors – they have also shut out retail investor opportunities. Our members are completely stifled by OSC requirements and this is contributing significantly to Ontario's weak economic performance. “- Anonymous NCFA member

See:  NCFA Submission to Ontario Ministry of Finance: Urgent Need for Regulatory Change

On behalf of the burden reduction committee at NCFA, we look forward to contributing ongoing input into Ontario’s burden reduction initiatives. Please contact us at any time to discuss further.

 

Sincerely,

 

Craig Asano
CEO & Founder
NCFA
casano@ncfacanada.org
(416) 618-0254

 

Download the full submission (34 page PDF) -> here


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden The National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

Latest news - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory BurdenFF Logo 400 v3 - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burdencommunity social impact - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden
Coronavirus resources 800 1 - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden

NCFA Newsletter subscribe600 - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden

FFCON20 Homepage Banner v3 updated - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden

NCFA Canada | March 25, 2020 JOIN US ON A STORYTELLING JOURNEY EVERY FRIDAY. Mar 25:  Why identity matters in an evolving online environment HOST: Tristram Waye, Fintech Friday's podcast episode GUEST: DAVID LUCATCH, President & Director – KABN Systems North America Inc. (Linkedin) KABN Links:  kabnsystemsna.com | liquidavatar.com About this episode: David Lucatch of KABN Networks North America joins Tristram Waye for this episode of Fintech Friday. David discusses why identity is a foundational element of the evolving online and data environment, and why KABN Networks North America has developed a business around it. During this episode he will also discuss: How KABN ID works and why it’s a foundational technology The suite of products KABN Networks North America has developed around identity and why Their vision of the future including the release of Liquid Avatar BIO: David Lucatch has spent more almost 35 years in the international marketing arena and over 25 years of that developing technologies and taking them to market.  David has held senior management posts and directorships at both private and public technology and media firms. David is an active supporter of numerous non-profit organizations and has been recognized and awarded internationally for his service and community ...
Read More
FF EP38 KABN Systems North America - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden
Guest Post | Pankaj Raghav | March 25, 2020 The entire world is dealing with the havoc of the coronavirus pandemic. Naturally, it will have a wreaking impact on the economy. The big events are being cancelled, flights are non-operational, and all sports leagues have been postponed. Almost every country across the globe is putting travel restrictions with an aim to keep the virus out of their home border. To combat the disease, the hospitals are bracing day in and day out, and public health officials are doing the best they can. Sadly, it isn’t easy being calm or optimistic in this dark time of crisis. However, as for the business owners, trying to be calm under crisis is a pivotal quality of their job description. So, if, as a business, you employ some proactive steps right away, you can get your business to be more safe and secure to recover faster post the crisis. China, the original epicenter of the Coronavirus, has started coming up with measures that are depicting clear signs of economic recovery. So, we have come up with 4 important steps and strategies that you need to implement to help your business recover post this pandemic ...
Read More
Coronavirus impact to your business - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden
The Globe and Mail OpEd | Cato Pastoll | March 24, 2020 No one planned for this. COVID-19 has brought the global economy to a standstill. With many provinces closing non-essential businesses, and consumption and consumer confidence decreasing, many Canadian small businesses are looking at extinction. Businesses surveyed by Lending Loop, on average, have less than 30 days of cash on hand to weather this storm. This is not a new finding. In 2016, a JP Morgan study showed that the average restaurant, retailer and manufacturer had 16, 19 and 30 days of cash on hand, respectively. As revenue declines continue in the coming weeks and months, their futures look incredibly bleak. By all accounts, the federal government knows small and medium-sized businesses constitute the backbone of our economy because they support at least 70 per cent of all jobs in Canada. Yet, the majority of our governments’ efforts are dedicated to supporting individuals and not businesses. While the enhanced Employment Insurance programs are helpful measures, the disappearance of our businesses would mean there would be no jobs to return to once the pandemic is over. See:  Lending Loop Surpasses $50 million Milestone and helps thousands of Canadian Businesses and ...
Read More
small business empty covid19 - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden
BCG Henderson Institute | Martin Reeves, Lars Faeste, Kevin Whitaker, and Mark Abraham | March 15, 2020 A rebound of demand is inevitable, and using high-frequency data proxies for the movement of goods and people, production and confidence, we can see that it is already beginning to happen in China. (See Exhibit 2.) Given the complexity of rebooting companies and supply chains at different speeds in different places, the time to begin preparing a rebound strategy is now. Over the past 100 years, epidemics have only temporarily deflected the economic cycle with short, sharp shocks. Of course, this time could be different. A bear market (technically a 20% decline) does not guarantee a recession but indicates a high probability of one. Prudent companies will prepare for this possibility. Our analysis shows that 14% of companies across all sectors actually grow top and bottom lines during recessions and downturns. Those who flourish share the common traits of preparation, preemption, growth orientation and long term transformation. They take a long term view and place growth bets when competitors are retrenching. And even after the epidemic recedes, and even in the case of recession, there will be opportunities and needs to reimagine business ...
Read More
light and forest trees - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden
Techopedia | Claudio Buttice | March 13, 2020 Before AI and the rise of FinTech, very few industry giants had the bandwidth to deal with the inherently quantitative nature of our now tech-savvy world. These AI use cases detail some of the ways AI has been a game-changer for FinTech. Banks alone are expected to spend $5.6 billion USD on AI and Machine Learning (ML) solutions in 2019 — just a fraction of what they’re expecting to earn since the profits generated may reach up to $250 billion USD in value. From automating the most menial and repetitive tasks to free up the time to focus on higher level objectives, to assisting with customer service management and reducing the risk of frauds, AI is employed from back-office tasks to the frontend with nimbleness and agility. 1. Fraud Detection and Compliance According to the Alan Turing Institute, with $70 billion USD spent by banks on compliance each year just in the U.S., the amount of money spent on fraud is staggering. And when the number of reported cases of payments-related fraud has increased by 66% between 2015 and 2016 in the United Kingdom, it’s clear how this problem is much more ...
Read More
AI winter is over - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden
Micky | Ali Qamar | March 21, 2020 The State of Hawaii has recently introduced a pilot program dubbed as the ‘Digital Currency Innovation Lab’ aimed at being a ‘testbed for innovation in the digital currency space.’ On March 17, Hawaii’s governor office revealed that the state’s very first state-initiated blockchain and cryptocurrency incubator is in the works. This initiative is in collaboration with three government agencies: Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs (DCCA) Hawaii Technology Development Corporation (HTDC) Division of Financial Institution (DFI) See:  10 ways regulators need to change in 2020 The main aim of the project is to assist digital currency issuers to do business in Hawaii without acquiring any sort of money transmitter license in the course of the effective period of the pilot program. The sandbox will remain in operation for the next two years. Furthermore, the program outlines three objectives: Create economic opportunities for Hawaii and foster early adoption of cryptocurrency Offer consumer protection and provide guidance to crypto entrepreneurs Provide data to shape crypto legislation in the state Sandbox participants protected against unlicensed regulation Iris Ikeda, Commissioner of Financial Institutions, highlighted that the DFI has issued a “no-action message” against unlicensed money transmission ...
Read More
Hawaii - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden
Betakit | Meagan Simpson | March 20, 2020 A survey conducted by Toronto-based FinTech startup Lending Loop has found that Canadian small businesses have seen an average revenue decline of more than 63 percent amid the COVID-19 pandemic. Lending Loop has been collecting data over the past few days from over 100 companies on the impact the COVID-19 outbreak is having on small businesses across Canada. In a Tweet on Thursday, Lending Loop CEO Cato Pastoll noted that the initial findings highlight the severity of the current situation. See:  Covid-19: Resources and Guides for Businesses and Individuals The small businesses surveyed have an average of 10 employees and according to the survey results have seen immediate impacts amid the current global situation. Those surveyed reported that their business has seen an average revenue loss of $1,141,310, leading to an average revenue decline of 63.3 percent. More than 65 percent of small businesses surveyed reported a revenue decline of more than 50 percent. With 92 percent concerned about their monthly obligations. The industries that have seen the largest hit are education services and restaurant and food services. Following closely behind are finance and insurance, as well as retail and wholesale trade ...
Read More
small business survey lending loop covid19 - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden
American Banker | Penny Crosman | March 18, 2020 The coronavirus pandemic could be devastating for many companies, but it's also shining a spotlight on the power of fintechs. They seem to be responding to the sudden challenge, though uncertainties lie ahead. The virus-driven moratorium on travel and the trend of companies encouraging people to work from home are changing the way people behave and communicate, and some of these changes could become permanent. “The behaviors that people can execute from their living room or from their den are going to grow, and behaviors that require face-to-face interaction or getting out into the community are going to diminish,” said Nigel Morris, managing partner of QED Investors and a co-founder of Capital One. “What does that mean? You should have greater mobile apps and digital adoption in general. If I had been holding off on signing up for PayPal, for instance, I might just do that.” Fintechs that help people do things remotely, like communicate about work, apply for a mortgage or make electronic payments, appear to be thriving, at least so far. Digital mortgages The digital mortgage software provider Blend, which has 230 bank clients, has also seen spikes in ...
Read More
digital mortages - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden
The Economist | March 21, 2020 Central-bank action is failing to stem the rout HOUSEHOLDS ARE frantically stocking up on essentials such as loo roll. But in financial markets, the staple that no one can do without in times of stress is cash—the flushing mechanism of the world economy. In theory, it should never dry up; money can be printed. When firms are desperate for cash it puts a potentially devastating strain on the plumbing of the global financial system. That is why in the past week America’s Federal Reserve has unleashed a huge amount of liquidity. Foreign central banks have joined in. Many face the additional challenge of a strengthening dollar. Unlike the 2007-09 financial crisis, when problems in the financial system caused an economic meltdown, the spread of the covid-19 disease has caused a health and economic crisis that has caught banks, financial markets and business in its wake. Big and small firms realise that they are facing— at the least—months of scant revenues, yet still have bills and debts to pay. Some are better equipped than others (see left-hand chart). The operating expenses (opex), like wages and rent, of all nonbank S&P 500 companies in 2019 amounted ...
Read More
cash crisis in america - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden
The Toronto Star | Olga Kharif | March 17, 2020 Crypto entrepreneurs Tyler and Cameron Winklevoss are launching a marketplace for nifties, the tradable digital art that can sell for thousands of dollars. Nifty Gateway, a startup that the Winklevoss’s Gemini Trust Co. bought last year, is debuting a website Tuesday where consumers will be able to buy and sell digital collectibles from artists including Michael Kagan and Lyle Owerko. Kagan, known for his space exploration-themed work, has collaborated with singer Pharrell Williams on t-shirt designs and recently sold a work through Christie’s for $40,000. Works of photographer Owerko have graced the cover of Time magazine and been collected by the likes of Beyonce. Niftygateway.com will also sell a collection of digital art from MMA fighter Cris Cyborg. “I haven’t done anything like this before, which is all the more reason to do this now,” Owerko said in a phone interview. See:  3 Ways Digital Assets Will Reshape The World For the Winklevoss twins, who have been two of the earliest supporters of cryptocurrency, the marketplace is a way to tap into an emerging and potentially lucrative market for digital art. Unlike other digital renderings, these pieces are kept track ...
Read More
Tyler and Cameron Winkelvoss - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden

 

share save 171 16 - March 1, 2019:  NCFA Submission to the Ontario Securities Commission on Regulatory Burden