Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake

share save 171 16 - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake

NCFA | Richard Remillard | January 28, 2019

open banking - Open Banking: What’s Really at StakeA National Project

Open banking has many definitions and multiple characteristics. At its core though is the concept of empowerment – the empowerment of financial consumers, individuals and businesses alike, that comes from transferring control over financial information to clients away from established financial institutions.

Because of this potential which promises to democratize financial transactions, much has been said about open banking in recent years. And, insofar as Canada is concerned, all that talk misses the point.

Properly considered, open banking is the national project for the 21st century digital, mobile, connected economy.

The only real question is: can Canada build such a national project when it is having such difficulty getting national projects for the 20th century economy off the ground, out of the ground and out to market?

Think pipelines.

See:  Why Open Banking Represents a Seismic Shift for Fintech

Causes for Concern

Already, there are worrisome signs.

  1. First, we are behind other jurisdictions such as Great Britain and Australia and there are indications that other countries will soon follow suit. Just as the US has moved smartly to develop and sell its vast reserves of shale oil while Canada’s product remains landlocked so too we risk being leapfrogged by the likes of an Estonia on the open banking side.
  2. Second, governments are engaged in full consultation mode and the policy commentariat ranging from the CD Howe Institute to Canada 2020 have been cranking out papers and hosting events on open banking at a rapid rate. The federal government has set up an advisory council following the 2018 budget while other federal departments and agencies from the Bank of Canada to the Competition Bureau have already been pondering the issue. However, the general public remains outside the discourse which to-date has been confined to the chattering classes.
  3. Third, one key interest group is claiming territorial jurisdiction, namely established financial institutions. Just as First Nations have demanded that they be fully brought in to the pipeline approval process, so too have the chartered banks weighed in with admonitions to proceed with all due haste – but, slowly, very slowly.  Not wanting to be seen as anti-innovation and anti-consumer choice but also wanting to protect their fat margins that are derived from maintaining the status quo.
  4. Fourth, Canada’s record on financial innovation is not stellar. Capital has been flowing into fintech startups but there is nothing to suggest that Canada is at the global forefront of financial innovation adoption. These days, observers point to countries as diverse as Kenya and Singapore when looking to fintech leadership. And, then there’s China and the US each with a host of flagship firms and fintechs, often bundled together in novel ways.
  5. Fifth, part of the problem with pipelines as with open banking is the never ending federal-provincial jurisdictional turf battle. We can’t seem to get a national securities commission (another pipeline project that’s thoroughly gummed up) which does not appear to be a priority for anyone any more. For open banking to be truly comprehensive would likely require a level of federal-provincial cooperation that has not been much in evidence lately.

A 2019 fearless forecast: no open banking, any time soon and certainly not in 2019. For Canada to participate in this financial innovation bold leadership will be required from committed participants unafraid to shake up the established order to bring about the birth of a new way of doing things.

See:  Fintech firms want to shake up banking, and that worries the Fed

Creating the Winning Conditions

Left to its own devices, the policy process today would likely grind out a classic Canadian compromise of the kind that we excel in producing, much like promoting both environmental protection and a resources-based economy. However, in the realm of open banking, allowing things to unfold as they usually do will probably lead to a middle-of-the-road that really doesn’t position Canada for leadership in financial services innovation.

The main challenge facing proponents of open banking today is to identify and then proceed to implement the winning conditions that will be necessary to overcome regulatory and bureaucratic inertia.

Some of those winning conditions would include:

  • Developing a public engagement strategy in order to build the necessary bodyguard of support in key segments of society, including interest groups, elected officials and the general population;
  • Focusing on a limited number of key communications messages that would address the tangible benefits of open banking, as well as the opportunity costs of not proceeding down this path, to individuals and businesses; these messages would likely centre on control, choice, trust and security;
  • Taking advantage of the plethora of media opportunities that exist today to keep broadcasting out easily communicable messages and to respond to the no go/go slow squadrons that are now mobilizing.

 

Richard Remillard,

President, Remillard Consulting Group

NCFA Board Member

 


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake The National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

Latest news - Open Banking: What’s Really at StakeFF Logo 400 v3 - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stakecommunity social impact - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake

CONGRATULATIONS TO THE 2020 FINTECH DRAFT PITCHING AND DEMO COMPANY WINNERS!



FFCON20 Pitching and Demo Winners - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake



NCFA COVID 19 letter to government to support Fintechs and SMEs - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake

NCFA Newsletter subscribe600 - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake

McKinsey Global Institute | Sep 21, 2020 In 2015, the 193 member countries of the United Nations came together to commit to 17 Sustainable Development Goals. Goal 5 focused on gender equality and set the ambitious target of achieving gender equality and empowering women and girls everywhere by 2030. Five years later, large gender gaps remain across the world, and the early evidence suggests that the COVID-19 pandemic has had a regressive effect on gender equality. Learn More: Banking Must Take A Stand On Tough Social Issues Women In Fintech Will Play A Crucial Part In The Covid-19 Recovery Plan Black tech founders say venture capital needs to move past ‘diversity theater’ Three Big Things: The Most Important Forces Shaping the World Why venture capital firms need more women partners and entrepreneurs Why Older Entrepreneurs Have the Edge Gender Bias Contributes to Blocking Female Founders Out of Investment & Venture Capital. We Need to Fix This. Six steps to achieve financial gender parity this #IWD How can we ensure that the role of women in the workplace and in society is central to efforts to rebuild economies in the COVID-19 era, and that women do not fall further behind? As ...
Read More
Gender eqality - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
Roar Growth on Medium | Peggy van de Plassche | Sep 14, 2020 How to protect our economies and capitalize on the trend As Palantir filed for IPO (while also settling a score with Silicon Valley), news on the cybersecurity front has been grim since the start of the pandemic. One of the unintended consequences of COVID-19 and subsequently of the entire economy moving online was the exponential increase in the points of vulnerability both on the clients’ and employees’ sides. In addition, the uncertain and fearful global environment became a fertile ground for fraudsters. Accordingly, the spike in cyber security threats related to COVID-19 and specifically the influx of associated malware and phishing scams was fast, furious and global; more specifically, attacks against the financial sector increased 238% globally from the beginning of February to the end of April With the IMF estimating, back in 2018, that cybercrime was costing the world ~$100 billion to 350 billion annually (the equivalent to ~10 to 30 percent of banks’ net income globally) and was potentially threatening financial stability, what are the trends we can anticipate? Below are several areas where I see a lot of activity taking place, hence generating opportunity ...
Read More
cyber attacks increasing - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
BBC | Sep 21, 2020 Leaked documents involving about $2tn of transactions have revealed how some of the world's biggest banks have allowed criminals to move dirty money around the world. They also show how Russian oligarchs have used banks to avoid sanctions that were supposed to stop them getting their money into the West. It's the latest in a string of leaks over the past five years that have exposed secret deals, money laundering and financial crime. What are the FinCEN files? The FinCEN files are more than 2,500 documents, most of which were files that banks sent to the US authorities between 2000 and 2017. They raise concerns about what their clients might be doing. See:  Fintech & Cybersecurity: Key Risks and Solutions These documents are some of the international banking system's most closely guarded secrets. Banks use them to report suspicious behaviour but they are not proof of wrongdoing or crime. They were leaked to Buzzfeed News and shared with a group that brings together investigative journalists from around the world, which distributed them to 108 news organisations in 88 countries, including the BBC's Panorama programme. Hundreds of journalists have been sifting through the dense, technical documentation, ...
Read More
FinCEN Files - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
NCFA Canada | Sep 18, 2020 JOIN US ON A STORYTELLING JOURNEY EVERY FRIDAY. EP41:  40% pandemic growth, taking risks and innovating Insurtech in Canada GUEST: DANISH YUSUF, Founder and CEO, Zensurance BIO:  Danish Yusuf is the Founder and CEO of Zensurance, a Toronto-based technology company focused on building curated insurance solutions for business owners.  Danish is a former leader in McKinsey & Company's Digital Insurance practice, supporting insurance clients globally on defining their digital strategy. Prior to McKinsey, Danish was a software architect and developer at IBM Canada, covering everything from mainframe development to web development.  Danish earned a bachelor’s degree in Software Engineering from the University of Toronto and has an MBA from Harvard Business School. In 2018, he was named by Canadian Underwriter as one of the Top 10 Brokers Under 40 in the Canadian Property and Casualty industry.  Enjoy! Links: Danish Yusuf, Founder and CEO, Zensurance (LinkedIn) Zensurance  (website |  twitter) About this episode:  Danish Yusuf, Founder and CEO of Zensurance joins Craig Asano, Founder and CEO NCFA Canada for the kickoff episode of Season 3 of Fintech Fridays. They discuss Danish's entrepreneurial journey, the story behind the creation of Zensurance and dive into what it's ...
Read More
NCFA FF Podcast Ep41 Danish Yusuf Zensurance Banner - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
Techcrunch | Danny Crichton | Sep 20, 2020 It used to be “easy” to tell the American and Chinese economies apart. One was innovative, one made clones. One was a free market while the other demanded payments to a political party and its leadership, a corrupt wealth generating scam that by some estimates has netted top leaders billions of dollars. One kept the talent borders porous acting as a magnet for the world’s top brains while the other interviewed you in a backroom at the airport before imprisoning you on sedition charges (okay, that might have been both). The comparison was always facile yes, but it was easy and at least directionally accurate if failing on the specifics. Now though, the country that exported exploding batteries is pioneering quantum computing, while the country that pioneered the internet now builds planes that fall out of the sky (and good news, we’ve identified even more planes that might fall out of the sky at an airport near you!) TikTok’s success is many things, but it is quite frankly just an embarrassment for the United States. There are thousands of entrepreneurs and hundreds of venture capitalists swarming Silicon Valley and the other American ...
Read More
US and China politics - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
The Law Society UK | Giles Parsons | Sep 16, 2020 Everything a computer does includes copying; data is processed, written to memory, retrieved, and transmitted. Copyright is infringed when the 'expression of the intellectual creation of the author of the work' is copied.  So in order to allow the internet to function, the EU passed an exception in copyright law that allows temporary copying when that copying forms part of a transmission of a copyright work in a network. This isn’t an issue for people – we don’t 'copy' documents in the same way to read them. Perhaps use by AI would fall within exhaustion of rights – once a book has been sold, it can be read by both man and machine. But behind this is a bigger question: what use by AI of a copyright work should be allowed? Copyright does not protect ideas; it protects the expression of ideas. But drawing a neat line between the two has always been difficult. See:  How do intellectual property rights apply to AI? Machine learning software, using artificial neural networks, can learn from information it receives and reach decisions on its own volition, with limited or no human intervention ...
Read More
Copyright - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
AltFi | John Reynolds | Sep 16, 2020 Fintechs will be “even more important” coming out of lockdown than they were during lockdown helping smaller businesses return to normality, according to the British Business Bank (BBB), which has reported a £2m loss in the year ending March 2020. The government-backed bank, which is responsible for organising the CBILS, BBLS and other government emergency funding schemes, has updated the market on the impact that Covid-19 has had on financial institutions, businesses and its organisation in its annual report. It cited fintechs as playing “an important part of delivering emergency schemes during the crisis” adding “they will be even more important in the recovery, when the UK’s smaller businesses will still need to be served by a healthy, competitive and diverse finance market.” Starling Bank and OakNorth Bank are among the fintechs which have offered loans during the pandemic through the BBB. See:  Refusal to embrace open banking puts Canada behind yet another curve The annual report covers the period to the year ending March 2020 but the BBB offers an update on the impact of Covid-19. It said the Coronavirus Business Interruption Loan Scheme (CBILS) has 97 accredited lenders and, as of August 11, provided 60,000 loans worth £13.4bn. The ...
Read More
BBB 2020 Annual report - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
CNBC | Samantha Delouya There may be a changing of the guard underway in financials. The market caps of payment stocks like Visa and MasterCard have eclipsed the value of Wall Street's biggest banks, even as their balance sheets remain significantly smaller in comparison. Square, Visa, PayPal and MasterCard are collectively worth $1.07 trillion, while the "big six" banks, which include JPMorgan, Bank of America, Wells Fargo, Citigroup, Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs are worth less than $900 billion in total. A large portion of gains in market value have come in 2020, as investors continue to reward software-based tech companies amid the pandemic. The ETFMG Prime Mobile Payments ETF, which tracks mobile payments stocks, is up nearly 10% in 2020, while the Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund is down nearly 20% so far this year. See:  Fintech Acquisitions Show Sector Strength Despite Covid-19 Payment companies have increased their push into traditional banking over recent years, which investors have rewarded with further share gains. On Tuesday, Square announced that it will allow Cash-App users to access some of their earned wages ahead of schedule, incentivizing users to sign up for direct deposit through the application. PayPal-owned Venmo also allows its ...
Read More
market valuation - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
Investment Executive | Rudy Mezzetta | Sep 2, 2020 Increasing compliance requirements — such as enhanced know-your-product rules — provided cover for Canada’s banks to focus ever more exclusively on selling their in-house investment products, shutting out independent products and limiting client choice, says Sheila Murray, a corporate director and former president of CI Financial.  “Under the guise of compliance and risk aversion, and doing the right thing for their clients, [banks] moved in favour of their own products to the detriment of having a balanced product shelf,” Murray said, speaking on a panel presented by NEO Exchange on Wednesday. The topic: Ontario’s Capital Markets Modernization Taskforce consultation paper, released in July. Murray made the comments in support of a proposal in the paper that banks be directed to offer independent providers greater access to their distribution channels. The task force set a deadline for Sept. 7 for comments, and intends to provide a final report with recommendations to the Ontario Minister of Finance before the year’s end.  See:  NCFA Response to the Modernizing Ontario’s Capital Markets Consultation Taskforce “It’s a really difficult [issue], but I think [the task force] is going in the right direction of encouraging a more open shelf and transparency on the shelf,” Murray said.  In its paper, the task force proposed that closed product shelves/proprietary-only shelves be banned in the bank-owned ...
Read More
bay street toronto - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
McKinsey & Company | Chandana Asif, Max Flötotto, Tunde Olanrewaju, and Giuseppe Sofo | Sep 9, 2020 To navigate the economic fall-out from COVID-19, Europe’s fintechs will need to adjust their playbook. Fintechs have been on a roll. Fueled by generous amounts of venture capital funding, last year 24 financial services startups hit a valuation of more than $1 billion, bringing the global total of such highly valued “unicorns” to 58. Together, these and other fintechs have ushered in a revolution in customer experience: Consumers can now open an account or get a loan in a matter of minutes (instead of weeks or months), exchange and send money internationally at low or no fees, and buy products with instantly created no-interest installment plans. Fintechs have also upped the ante for speed and agility, launching new features and initiatives in weeks instead of the six- to twelve-month timeframes more typical of banks. See:  Setting up small and medium-size enterprises for restart and recovery The emergence and spread of COVID-19—in the first place a world health crisis—is also causing unprecedented economic damage across the globe. Most McKinsey COVID-19 scenarios show European economies contracting by 11 percent in 2020 and not returning to ...
Read More
Alternative path to profit - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake

 

share save 171 16 - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake