Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake

NCFA | Richard Remillard | January 28, 2019

open banking - Open Banking: What’s Really at StakeA National Project

Open banking has many definitions and multiple characteristics. At its core though is the concept of empowerment – the empowerment of financial consumers, individuals and businesses alike, that comes from transferring control over financial information to clients away from established financial institutions.

Because of this potential which promises to democratize financial transactions, much has been said about open banking in recent years. And, insofar as Canada is concerned, all that talk misses the point.

Properly considered, open banking is the national project for the 21st century digital, mobile, connected economy.

The only real question is: can Canada build such a national project when it is having such difficulty getting national projects for the 20th century economy off the ground, out of the ground and out to market?

Think pipelines.

See:  Why Open Banking Represents a Seismic Shift for Fintech

Causes for Concern

Already, there are worrisome signs.

  1. First, we are behind other jurisdictions such as Great Britain and Australia and there are indications that other countries will soon follow suit. Just as the US has moved smartly to develop and sell its vast reserves of shale oil while Canada’s product remains landlocked so too we risk being leapfrogged by the likes of an Estonia on the open banking side.
  2. Second, governments are engaged in full consultation mode and the policy commentariat ranging from the CD Howe Institute to Canada 2020 have been cranking out papers and hosting events on open banking at a rapid rate. The federal government has set up an advisory council following the 2018 budget while other federal departments and agencies from the Bank of Canada to the Competition Bureau have already been pondering the issue. However, the general public remains outside the discourse which to-date has been confined to the chattering classes.
  3. Third, one key interest group is claiming territorial jurisdiction, namely established financial institutions. Just as First Nations have demanded that they be fully brought in to the pipeline approval process, so too have the chartered banks weighed in with admonitions to proceed with all due haste – but, slowly, very slowly.  Not wanting to be seen as anti-innovation and anti-consumer choice but also wanting to protect their fat margins that are derived from maintaining the status quo.
  4. Fourth, Canada’s record on financial innovation is not stellar. Capital has been flowing into fintech startups but there is nothing to suggest that Canada is at the global forefront of financial innovation adoption. These days, observers point to countries as diverse as Kenya and Singapore when looking to fintech leadership. And, then there’s China and the US each with a host of flagship firms and fintechs, often bundled together in novel ways.
  5. Fifth, part of the problem with pipelines as with open banking is the never ending federal-provincial jurisdictional turf battle. We can’t seem to get a national securities commission (another pipeline project that’s thoroughly gummed up) which does not appear to be a priority for anyone any more. For open banking to be truly comprehensive would likely require a level of federal-provincial cooperation that has not been much in evidence lately.

A 2019 fearless forecast: no open banking, any time soon and certainly not in 2019. For Canada to participate in this financial innovation bold leadership will be required from committed participants unafraid to shake up the established order to bring about the birth of a new way of doing things.

See:  Fintech firms want to shake up banking, and that worries the Fed

Creating the Winning Conditions

Left to its own devices, the policy process today would likely grind out a classic Canadian compromise of the kind that we excel in producing, much like promoting both environmental protection and a resources-based economy. However, in the realm of open banking, allowing things to unfold as they usually do will probably lead to a middle-of-the-road that really doesn’t position Canada for leadership in financial services innovation.

The main challenge facing proponents of open banking today is to identify and then proceed to implement the winning conditions that will be necessary to overcome regulatory and bureaucratic inertia.

Some of those winning conditions would include:

  • Developing a public engagement strategy in order to build the necessary bodyguard of support in key segments of society, including interest groups, elected officials and the general population;
  • Focusing on a limited number of key communications messages that would address the tangible benefits of open banking, as well as the opportunity costs of not proceeding down this path, to individuals and businesses; these messages would likely centre on control, choice, trust and security;
  • Taking advantage of the plethora of media opportunities that exist today to keep broadcasting out easily communicable messages and to respond to the no go/go slow squadrons that are now mobilizing.


Richard Remillard,

President, Remillard Consulting Group

NCFA Board Member


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake The National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit:

Latest news - Open Banking: What’s Really at StakeFF Logo 400 v3 - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stakecommunity social impact - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake

Want to get insider access to some of the most innovative advances happening in #fintech. Join us May 31, 2023 in Toronto for an in-person 7th Summer Kickoff Networking!

Grab your May 31 ticket before they are gone...

7th Summer Kickoff Networking May 31 Presented by DIGTL 1000 1 - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake

Support NCFA by Following us on Twitter!

NCFA Sign up for our newsletter - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake

FundRazr | Daryl Hatton | May 28, 2023 FundRazr, a well-known fundraising platform, has launched an Environmental Fundraising Spotlight (free of charge) until July 2023. This initiative aims to provide a special focus on campaigns that are raising funds for various environmental causes, such as wildlife and marine life protection, ocean and sea conservation, preservation of natural habitat and resources, biodiversity, and land and forestry. See:  FINTECH FRIDAY$ (EP24-Feb 8): Re-imagining Philanthropy with Daryl Hatton, Founder and CEO of ConnectionPoint/FundRazr Benefit:  Participating organizations stand to benefit from increased visibility through FundRazr's paid social media promotions and advice from btheir digital fundraising strategists. These efforts are meant to attract more donors and ensure the campaign's success. This initiative is not only an opportunity to raise funds for the cause but also to gain a wider network and increase awareness for environmental protection. The Environmental Fundraising Spotlight is free of charge, with FundRazr investing in paid advertising to support the participating environmental movements. The only deductions from the raised money are standard third-party payment processing fees determined by the selected payment processor. To maintain the free usage of the platform, an optional tip is requested from supporters. FundRazr provides a range of ...
Read More
Fundrazr environmental campaign spotlight - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
The Block | Yogita Khatri | May 27, 2023 Beijing has released a comprehensive white paper, titled "Web3 Innovation and Development White Paper (2023)," promoting the advancement of web3 technologies. China's Evolving Crypto Stance: Beijing's authorities view web3 as a pivotal trend in the internet industry's evolution. They're committing substantial resources, with Beijing's Chaoyang district pledging 100 million yuan (~$14 million) annually until 2025, to transform Beijing into a global digital economy innovation hub. Despite banning cryptocurrency use in 2021, China seems to be progressively warming up to the crypto industry. The white paper signals this shift, with Beijing actively promoting the development of web3, a technology intimately tied to blockchain and cryptocurrencies. This week's segment by China Central Television, featuring Bitcoin and NFTs - though subsequently removed - further corroborates the softening stance. See:  10 Most Innovative Companies in 2023: Blockchain, Crypto, Metaverse, Web3 Synchronized Timing: The release of Beijing's web3 white paper coincides interestingly with new crypto regulations in Hong Kong. Binance CEO Changpeng Zhao pointed out that Hong Kong's new crypto rules come into effect from June 1, indicating a broader shift in Asia's digital economy and regulatory landscape. This timing suggests a coordinated regional strategy towards ...
Read More
Web3 in China - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
CBC News | May 26, 2023 Brain implant company says U.S. regulator approval is 'important first step' to launching their technology FDA Greenlights Neuralink for Human Trials: Neuralink, the innovative brain-implant company led by serial entrepreneur Elon Musk, announced that it has secured approval from U.S. regulators to initiate testing its pioneering device in human subjects. This marks a significant milestone for the tech giant, opening up unprecedented possibilities in the realm of neurotechnology. Neuralink's Promise for Treating Brain Disorders and Injuries: The device, a revolutionary brain-computer interface about the size of a large coin, is designed to be implanted in the skull, potentially restoring vision and improving motor control in patients. Musk's vision extends to bridging signals from the brain to Neuralink devices in the spinal cord, which could offer transformative treatment options for severe neurological conditions. See:  16z: 2023 State of Crypto (and Index) The Beginning of a New Era in Neurotech: Despite the remarkable promise of this technology, it's still considered an "investigational device" and its safety and efficacy are yet to be fully established. The approval for clinical trials signifies the beginning of an exciting era in neurotechnology, promising unprecedented advancements in understanding and treating brain-related ...
Read More
Freepik jcomp brain - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
Wealth Professional | Steve Randall | May 26, 2023 A recent international study conducted by the CFA Institute and the FINRA Foundation focused on the investment behaviors of Gen Z individuals (aged 18-34) in Canada, the US, UK, and China. The study emphasized the need for governments, regulators, and investment professionals to support Gen Z by providing them with the necessary knowledge and educational tools to make informed investment decisions. It also noted the impact of macroeconomic factors, the rise of cryptocurrency, and the influence of social media "finfluencers" on the investment habits of this cohort. See:  Early-stage Investing – The Public gets a Seat at the Table The study revealed several key findings: Gen Z Canadians exhibit the highest level of investing activity among the four countries surveyed, with 74% owning at least one investment product. This figure surpasses China (57%), the US (56%), and the UK (49%). The fear of missing out (FOMO) was identified as the primary motivator for 40% of Canadian Gen Z individuals to start investing. Access to financial advice through social media and the availability of investing apps and cryptocurrencies were identified as significant factors influencing investment decisions. Cryptocurrencies served as the starting point ...
Read More
Women checking portfolio online - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
May 26, 2023 Technology and software are taking over the world, and there is software for almost anything you can imagine. As of 2022, the software industry was $474.61 billion and is projected to grow by 11.9% between now and 2030. As you would expect in any high-value industry, software development attracts quite a crowd, but only the best stand out. It takes a lot to create software that stands out, and as a developer, you want to be sure you profit from your efforts. This guide focuses on patent registration and can be an excellent read if you are in the software development industry. What Are Patents Patents are a form of IP protection extended by a government to innovators with groundbreaking ideas. For an idea to qualify for patent registration, it must be new, useful, and non-obvious. New means the innovation must be the first in the world. Usefulness means that the invention must have a practical application. Lastly, non-obvious means the invention must not be something another person trained in the field can easily create. The applicant must also provide detailed information on the subject of registration in such a way that another person skilled in the ...
Read More
Unsplash Danial Igdery Person coding on device - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
The Defiant | Samuel Haig  | May 24, 2023 In a push to revive its downtrend and amplify adoption, Solana, a Layer 1 blockchain noted for quick, low-cost transactions, launched a ChatGPT plugin that enhances its user interface. Solana AI ChatGPT plugin: The plugin facilitates various actions including NFT purchasing, token transfers, and on-chain data analysis, making it a powerful tool for those developing consumer-oriented applications. Future iterations are expected to enable the writing and deployment of smart contracts on-chain, making the Solana blockchain more accessible and user-friendly. See:  Solana DeFi Is Starting Over — OpenBook Signs of Live Despite Market Challenges: Despite a significant 92% drop from its 2021 highs, Solana has started to recover, showing an 80% increase in the SOL token this year. However, the project faced various challenges including outages, criticisms regarding decentralization, and significant market share loss to other low-cost Layer 1s. The downfall of FTX and Alameda Research, significant Solana investors, also dealt a blow to the ecosystem. Solana persists and looks to AI as a means to regain momentum and foster growth. Boost for AI Grant Accelerator Program: In a bid to nurture the development of machine learning models interacting with Solana-based protocols, ...
Read More
Solana - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
CanadaHelps | May 26, 2023 It’s easy to join the Great Canadian Giving Challenge June 1-30, 2023! Enter to win $20,000 for any Charity*: 1. Search: Find your favourite charity that you want to help win. 2. Donate: Every $1 donated this June on is a chance to win!* 3. Celebrate: Feel good knowing the impact your donation made and wait to see if your gift is the winning donation when the grand prize winner is drawn on July 1st, 2022! Learn more --> Now Also accepting crypto donations!  The National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: ...
Read More
CanadaHelps Great Canadian Giving Challenge2 - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
Coinsmart | Justin Hartzman | May 25, 2023 Binance's recent withdrawal from the Canadian market due to regulatory concerns has sparked fear and uncertainty among the community. However, contrary to popular belief, strict crypto regulations in Canada aim to enhance investor safety and foster a thriving industry ecosystem. Binance's Exit Explained:Binance's withdrawal from the Canadian market is linked to the new regulations introduced by the Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA). These regulations require crypto asset trading platforms (CTPs) to meet specific requirements. They include segregating client assets Appointing a Chief Compliance Officer Prohibiting leveraged trading Banning stablecoins Failure to comply leads to cessation of operations. Binance, along with OKX and DyDx, has exited the Canadian market due to these regulations. See:  PwC Partner and Fintech Lead Interview: “Fintech is Becoming Crypto’ The need for crypto regulations in Canada arose after the industry suffered from a "crypto contagion" in 2022, resulting in financial losses for individuals and institutions. Regulations aim to protect citizens, stabilize the banking system, combat fraud, enhance digital security, prevent illicit activities, and establish industry standards. Regulations should be approached with caution, aiming to protect consumers while fostering innovation. Collaborative efforts between regulators and industry leaders are crucial for ...
Read More
Coinsmart Crypto regulation in Canada - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
The Guardian | Kalyeena Makortoff  | May 25, 2023 Anne Boden, the founder and CEO of Starling Bank, has made the surprising decision to step down as chief executive in order to avoid potential conflicts of interest as a major shareholder. She believes that the roles and priorities of a shareholder and a CEO ultimately differ and wants to ensure there is no conflict. Boden, who launched Starling Bank in 2014, will relinquish her executive role next month but remain on the board as a non-executive director. She initiated discussions about her departure six months ago, and her decision was not prompted by UK regulators or the board. See:  Research: Which UK Bank Customers are Most at Risk of Fraud? Starling Bank, which has 3.6 million customers, recently announced that its revenues for the year ending March 2023 have more than doubled to £453m, leading to its second consecutive year of annual profits. The bank will be temporarily led by its chief operating officer while searching for a permanent replacement for Boden. “Now that we have grown from being an aspiring challenger to an established bank, it is clear the roles and priorities of a CEO and a large shareholder ...
Read More
Image Starling Bank PR - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
May 26, 2023 Investing your money is one of the most important things you can do for your financial future. By investing wisely, you can set yourself up for long-term financial stability and security. In this article, we'll take a look at some of the key things you need to know about investing for your future. Why Invest? The first question you might have is: why invest at all? There are several reasons why investing your money is a smart choice: Grow Your Money: Investing your money allows you to potentially earn a higher return than you would get from a savings account or other low-risk investment. Beat Inflation: Inflation can eat away at the value of your money over time. By investing, you can potentially earn a return that beats the rate of inflation, helping you stay ahead financially. Meet Financial Goals: Whether you're saving for a down payment on a house or planning for retirement, investing can help you achieve your financial goals. Types of Investments There are many different types of investments you can make, each with their own unique risks and potential rewards. Some common types of investments include: Stocks: When you buy a share of ...
Read More
Freepik storyset investing - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

3 × 5 =