2022 Fintech and Funding Conference (FFCON22: REGEN) | Dec 1 + Dec 6, 2022 Hybrid

Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake

NCFA | Richard Remillard | January 28, 2019

open banking - Open Banking: What’s Really at StakeA National Project

Open banking has many definitions and multiple characteristics. At its core though is the concept of empowerment – the empowerment of financial consumers, individuals and businesses alike, that comes from transferring control over financial information to clients away from established financial institutions.

Because of this potential which promises to democratize financial transactions, much has been said about open banking in recent years. And, insofar as Canada is concerned, all that talk misses the point.

Properly considered, open banking is the national project for the 21st century digital, mobile, connected economy.

The only real question is: can Canada build such a national project when it is having such difficulty getting national projects for the 20th century economy off the ground, out of the ground and out to market?

Think pipelines.

See:  Why Open Banking Represents a Seismic Shift for Fintech

Causes for Concern

Already, there are worrisome signs.

  1. First, we are behind other jurisdictions such as Great Britain and Australia and there are indications that other countries will soon follow suit. Just as the US has moved smartly to develop and sell its vast reserves of shale oil while Canada’s product remains landlocked so too we risk being leapfrogged by the likes of an Estonia on the open banking side.
  2. Second, governments are engaged in full consultation mode and the policy commentariat ranging from the CD Howe Institute to Canada 2020 have been cranking out papers and hosting events on open banking at a rapid rate. The federal government has set up an advisory council following the 2018 budget while other federal departments and agencies from the Bank of Canada to the Competition Bureau have already been pondering the issue. However, the general public remains outside the discourse which to-date has been confined to the chattering classes.
  3. Third, one key interest group is claiming territorial jurisdiction, namely established financial institutions. Just as First Nations have demanded that they be fully brought in to the pipeline approval process, so too have the chartered banks weighed in with admonitions to proceed with all due haste – but, slowly, very slowly.  Not wanting to be seen as anti-innovation and anti-consumer choice but also wanting to protect their fat margins that are derived from maintaining the status quo.
  4. Fourth, Canada’s record on financial innovation is not stellar. Capital has been flowing into fintech startups but there is nothing to suggest that Canada is at the global forefront of financial innovation adoption. These days, observers point to countries as diverse as Kenya and Singapore when looking to fintech leadership. And, then there’s China and the US each with a host of flagship firms and fintechs, often bundled together in novel ways.
  5. Fifth, part of the problem with pipelines as with open banking is the never ending federal-provincial jurisdictional turf battle. We can’t seem to get a national securities commission (another pipeline project that’s thoroughly gummed up) which does not appear to be a priority for anyone any more. For open banking to be truly comprehensive would likely require a level of federal-provincial cooperation that has not been much in evidence lately.

A 2019 fearless forecast: no open banking, any time soon and certainly not in 2019. For Canada to participate in this financial innovation bold leadership will be required from committed participants unafraid to shake up the established order to bring about the birth of a new way of doing things.

See:  Fintech firms want to shake up banking, and that worries the Fed

Creating the Winning Conditions

Left to its own devices, the policy process today would likely grind out a classic Canadian compromise of the kind that we excel in producing, much like promoting both environmental protection and a resources-based economy. However, in the realm of open banking, allowing things to unfold as they usually do will probably lead to a middle-of-the-road that really doesn’t position Canada for leadership in financial services innovation.

The main challenge facing proponents of open banking today is to identify and then proceed to implement the winning conditions that will be necessary to overcome regulatory and bureaucratic inertia.

Some of those winning conditions would include:

  • Developing a public engagement strategy in order to build the necessary bodyguard of support in key segments of society, including interest groups, elected officials and the general population;
  • Focusing on a limited number of key communications messages that would address the tangible benefits of open banking, as well as the opportunity costs of not proceeding down this path, to individuals and businesses; these messages would likely centre on control, choice, trust and security;
  • Taking advantage of the plethora of media opportunities that exist today to keep broadcasting out easily communicable messages and to respond to the no go/go slow squadrons that are now mobilizing.

 

Richard Remillard,

President, Remillard Consulting Group

NCFA Board Member

 


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake The National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

Latest news - Open Banking: What’s Really at StakeFF Logo 400 v3 - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stakecommunity social impact - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake

Support NCFA by Following us on Twitter!







NCFA Sign up for our newsletter - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake




BankingDive | Anna Hrushka | Sep 23, 2022 Sen. Elizabeth Warren, D-MA, called the peer-to-peer payments network “unsafe,” claiming Zelle users were defrauded out of $500 million last year. “You have created a perfect weapon for criminals to use and they have used it and you have not stood behind your customers,” she told the witnesses, which included the CEOs of JPMorgan Chase, Bank of America, Wells Fargo, Citi, Truist, PNC and U.S. Bank. Zelle, a network designed to compete with P2P fintechs such as Venmo and Cash App, is owned by six of the seven banks represented at Thursday’s Senate Banking Committee hearing. Senate Democrats on Thursday pressed the CEOs of the nation’s largest retail banks to answer for scams associated with Zelle, a bank-owned peer-to-peer payments network, calling for the institutions to implement policies to protect and redress customers defrauded through the platform. See: Asset Managers, Banks Are Tightening Controls of Communication Tools like WhatsApp Some New Banking Rules Implemented to Protect Consumers in Canada In a joint letter sent to Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) Director Rohit Chopra in April, the Democratic lawmakers called on the regulator to expand the definition of “error payments” to include payments ...
Read More
Ms Warren at Zelle senate hearing - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
TechCrunch | Anita Ramaswamy | Sep 20, 2022 Sardine announced it has raised $51.5 million in a Series B round led by Andreessen Horowitz’s (a16z) Growth Fund after closing $19.5 million for its Series A earlier this year.  “Faster instant payments mean faster fraud,” Sardine CEO and co-founder Soups Ranjan told TechCrunch. That’s the thesis behind his startup, which uses behavioral, financial and device-specific user data to detect fraud on behalf of its clients in the crypto and fintech industries. Growth: Sardine has grown considerably since it announced the Series A back in February, growing its roster of clients from ~50 to ~135 today, Ranjan said. Its customers include crypto exchanges FTX and Blockchain.com as well as fintechs with broader mandates such as Wealthsimple and Digit, he added. See:  Consumer Protection: Fintech Complaints Have Been Rising Differentiators: Sardine’s differentiation in the market as stemming from his team’s experience and the company’s focus on fintechs. Another major differentiator from competitors like Socure is its instant ACH and card onramp to crypto, which allows its customers to purchase over 30 different crypto assets instantly. Banks and card issuers typically use fraud detection algorithms for crypto that aren’t nearly granular enough.  Around half ...
Read More
Fishy transactions - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
Clyde&Co | Sep 21, 2022 On June 29, 2022, the Quebec government presented the draft Regulation respecting confidentiality incidents (the “Quebec Regulation”). The Quebec Regulation specifies the content of the new notification and record-keeping requirements following the occurrence of a confidentiality incident. The regulation is set to enter into force on September 22, 2022, along with the first amendments to Quebec's Act respecting the protection of personal information in the private sector (the “Private Sector Act”), following the adoption of Bill 64,  An Act to modernize legislative provisions as regards the protection of personal information (“Bill 64”). See:  5 Billion Profiles: Class Action Lawsuit Accuses Oracle of Privacy Breach and “Global Surveillance” Bill 64 received assent on September 22, 2021, which marked the start of Quebec's transition into modernizing the rules that apply to the protection of personal information. We recently published an insight which provides an overview of the amendments that Bill 64 is bringing along for the next few years. What is a confidentiality incident? As amended by Bill 64, Section 3.6 of the Private Sector Act provides the following definition of a “confidentiality incident”: access not authorized by law to personal information; use not authorized by law ...
Read More
Quebec Draft regulation on confidentiailty incidents - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
Investment Executive | Greg Meckbach | Sep 16, 2022 Open banking — available in Britain but not yet in Canada — is when a financial institution shares client account details (with consent) with a third party, without the client having to share their login name and password.   In 2021, a government-appointed advisory committee recommended that open banking be up and running by January 2023. In the committee’s proposed initial phase, third-party service providers (such as fintechs) should be able to read data from clients’ chequing and savings accounts, investments accounts, RRSPs, TFSAs and non-registered accounts that hold stocks, bonds, mutual funds and GICs, the committee said in its final report. Open banking should be mandatory for federally regulated banks and optional for provincially regulated institutions and “other entities,” the report added. Fee comparison:  Armed with such data, a third-party fintech could potentially tell a consumer how much they could save on fees, said Stephanie Holmes-Winton, CEO and founder of Halifax-based fintech CacheFlo Inc. Through open banking, a fintech could learn that a client has multiple accounts at different institutions with similar investments in them. The fintech could then compare the fees, Holmes-Winton said. See: Canada’s Open Banking Journey: Interview with ...
Read More
Fintech open banking - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
The Defiant | Owen Fernau  | Sep 22, 2022 Agency Alleges Ooki DAO Offered Derivatives Without a License In a case that has roiled the crypto community and triggered a dissent from one its own officials, the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) brought an enforcement action yesterday that challenges fundamental tenets of decentralized finance. On Sept. 22, the regulator alleged in a lawsuit that a DAO called Ooki DAO engaged in activities that only regulated entities called futures commission merchants (FCM) can perform. The DAO illegally offered leveraged and marginal retail commodity transactions in digital assets, which are derivatives, and agreed to pay a $250,000 penalty, the CFTC said. The commission also named the venture’s founders, Tom Bean and Kyle Kistner, in the suit. See:  New U.S. Bill Gives Crypto Oversight to the CFTC The CFTC’s actions suggest that calling an entity a DAO, or invoking token-based voting as part of an organization’s decision-making process, doesn’t necessarily protect that entity from the legal responsibilities of a traditionally regulated institution. CFTC Commissioner Summer Mersinger - broke rank with her five fellow commissioners and said: The action wasn’t supported by the Commodity Exchange Act, the law that regulates derivatives inssuance, and amounted ...
Read More
CFTC - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
Betakit | Josh Scott | Sep 21, 2022 FrontFundr has launched its own fundraising campaign on FrontFundr, which the company said will remain open to the public until November 4. Toronto-based FrontFundr has announced that it has helped startups raise over $140 million across more than 100 fundraising campaigns using its equity crowdfunding platform. Since Canadian regulators introduced harmonized crowdfunding rules across Canada, making equity crowdfunding more accessible, Van Hoeken has seen its popularity rise, especially as broader economic conditions have worsened. So far, FrontFundr has raised a total of $7.3 million CAD from over 900 investors. The company aims to raise another $2.5 million to $5 million through its latest offering to support its product development plans and boost its sales. To date, FrontFundr has built a community of more than 30,000 users. The startup’s platform has helped Canadian tech startups like Manzil, Caary, and FrontFundr itself raise capital. Van Hoeken also sees a future where FrontFundr can help more public companies raise money using its platform. Over the longer-term, FrontFundr has ambitions to “spread [its] wings” across North America and into the United States. See:  Fintech Fridays EP57: 10 Years of Investment Crowdfunding: Past, Present & Future Since ...
Read More
FrontFundrs team Sep 2022 - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
Coinsmart | Release | Sep 22, 2022 TORONTO, Sept. 22, 2022 /CNW/ - CoinSmart Financial Inc. ("CoinSmart" or the "Company") (NEO: SMRT) (FSE: IIR), announced today that it has entered into a definitive agreement dated September 22, 2022 (the "Purchase Agreement") with Coinsquare Ltd. ("Coinsquare"), a leading Canadian crypto asset trading platform, pursuant to which CoinSmart has agreed to sell to Coinsquare all of the issued and outstanding shares of its wholly-owned operating subsidiary Simply Digital Technologies Inc. ("Simply Digital") (the "Transaction"). The acquisition and integration of these two businesses will establish Coinsquare as one of Canada's largest crypto asset trading platforms with a diversified and compliant offering across various business lines, including both retail and institutional trading, crypto payment processing, and digital asset custody. CoinSmart will hold approximately 12% ownership in Coinsquare on a pro-forma basis. The combined company has transacted over $10 billion since January 2018, and will have over $350 million in assets under custody with a combined user base in excess of 1 million. See:  FINTECH FRIDAY$ (EP23-Feb 1): Getting Smart About Crypto and Insurtech Snapchat Models – Interview with Justin Hartzman, Co-founder and CEO of Coinsmart Crypto Exchange CoinSmart Co-Founders Justin Hartzman, Jeremy Koven, and ...
Read More
Coinsmart - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
For Bitvo by Tristram Waye | Sep 22, 2022 Power of expectations and some broad elements that may impact your trading The deeper you get into the trading arena, the more you will notice the power of expectations.  Expectations shape pricing and the moves in response to news and events.  They shape how market participants reflexively respond and reposition which further influences prices and policies.  And that means that expectations affect your trading decisions. The Fed and the economic data:  We will be focused on the US because the Federal Reserve can be considered the world’s central bank.   These reports give some insight into the economic conditions taking place. Some of these have a lag. Others are more recent. And there are other reports that give more granular insights into business conditions and numerous other metrics.  See:  Should You Be Hedging Your Crypto Trading? These data points have varying relevance and importance based on circumstances in the real world. So one data point might be a focal point in one period and of little relevance in another. And, of course, there are seasonal trends in many data points. Right now, there is a focus on inflation. Inflation management falls to ...
Read More
Power of expectations - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
NfX | Pete Flint | Sep 2022 Affordability issues breeding innovation:  Real estate has always been more than just the largest asset class in the world. It is the embodiment of home and work, family and business – the opportunity of generational wealth, writ large. The American dream.  One that has become increasingly out of reach to most Americans. Paths to ownership of real estate are expanding. What “ownership” even means is also expanding. Affordability and access to traditional home ownership has only eroded since the housing bubble in 2008, as lending standards tightened and home prices have soared in recent years. And yet, restriction breeds innovation and market changes create opportunity. From the front lines with proptech Founders, we’re seeing early signs of a real estate revolution. See:  Vancouver Proptech Startup addy Launches Canada’s First Crowdfunded Real Estate Investing App Real Estate 1.0: The Information Revolution:  The first phase of tech adoption in the home-buying process was Real Estate 1.0, an information revolution enabled by the internet. The problem was the lack of information about one of the most important financial decisions a person can make: buying or selling a home. Real Estate 2.0: The Transaction Revolution: Streamlining the ...
Read More
Real estate as a percentage of real assets - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake
TechCrunch | Carly Page | Sep 20, 2022 Fintech startup Revolut has confirmed it was hit by a highly targeted cyberattack that allowed hackers to access the personal details of tens of thousands of customers. Response: Revolut spokesperson Michael Bodansky told TechCrunch: an “unauthorized third party obtained access to the details of a small percentage (0.16%) of our customers for a short period of time.” Revolut discovered the malicious access late on September 11 and isolated the attack by the following morning.  We immediately identified and isolated the attack to effectively limit its impact and have contacted those customers affected.  Customers who have not received an email have not been impacted." See:  Revolut executive resigns amid growing tensions with the FCA over banking license In a message sent to affected customers posted to Reddit, the company said that “no card details, PINs or passwords were accessed.” However, the breach disclosure states that hackers likely accessed partial card payment data, along with customers’ names, addresses, email addresses and phone numbers. How many customers:  first spotted by Bleeping Computer, the company says 50,150 customers were impacted by the breach, including 20,687 customers in the European Economic Area and 379 Lithuanian citizens. How did ...
Read More
Revolut  - Open Banking: What’s Really at Stake

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

twenty + six =