Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”

Jericho Chambers | by Margaret Heffernan | March 2019

open - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”Some years ago, I joined a conference hosted by one of Silicon Valley’s top venture capitalists. It was the kind of event I knew well, when all the CEOs funded by the VC gather together to compare notes on what they’re seeing in the market place and are provided with (or subjected to) some pearls of wisdom from those with more experience.

Once upon a time, I was one of those CEOs, now I was supposed to dispense wisdom about willful blindness. I don’t remember much about the conference beyond its opening which went something along these lines:

There is nothing wrong with medicine that getting rid of doctors won’t fix.
There is nothing wrong with education that getting rid of teachers won’t fix.
There’s nothing wrong with the legal system that getting rid of lawyers won’t fix.

… our host stopped just short of saying there was nothing wrong with democracy that getting rid of voters won’t fix….

I sat up and paid attention. This was not the tech sector as I’d known it. All those years back in what I’ve come to think of as Internet 1.0 we had been full of curiosity, wondering what new wonders we could invent with this new tech and how we might develop it to enable, empower and even liberate everyone.

“We were idealists, we were naïve”

We hadn’t gone into it to make money – there wasn’t any in the beginning. And we hadn’t gone into it for power – there wasn’t much of that either. We were idealists, we were naïve.

See:  #FFCON19 talked about how to build trust in the 21st century

How things had changed. Now the full force of Big Tech was marshalling its overwhelming power against … teachers? Doctors? This was definitely different, a calculated attack on society as we know it.

Since the early days tech has become so much bigger, richer, more aggressive. It tricks kids into spending money, newly weds and parents into buying stuff they didn’t know they were buying, recruiting subjects for experiments no one knew they were part of, siphoning off data. Who knows what else can be laid against its door?

This is not the way to build trust. It is a way to build distrust.  And nowhere is that deeper than in discussions about artificial intelligence.

But first, what do I mean by trust? According to Veronica Hope-Hailey’s rich research, it is a mix of 4 ingredients

  • Benevolence: you wish the best for me, for all of us

  • Competency: you know what you’re doing

  • Consistency: you don’t change your mind or lie

  • Integrity: you act the same way when nobody’s looking

But even in its early phase, these four qualities are notably absent in corporate experiments with AI. Instead, there are a whole bunch of problems that, thanks to diligent investigators, keep being brought to light.

No consent

Earlier this year, it was revealed that Pearson, a major AI-education vendor, inserted “social-psychological interventions” into one of its commercial learning software programs to test how 9,000 students would respond. They did this without the consent or knowledge of students, parents, or teachers.115

This doesn’t appear to be consistent with Pearson’s values nor does it exude integrity.

Bias

96 percent of the world’s code has been written by men. And there’s an army of scientists (if you need them) who have demonstrated that WHAT is made/ written is a reflection of those who make it.  (In art, this is deemed a virtue.) So it means that we already start in a deeply troubled, profoundly unrepresentative place.

Using AI for hiring selection has been shown – by Amazon – to be ineradicably biased because, trained on historical data of overwhelmingly male employees, it selects…overwhelmingly male employees, and deselects women. After 2 years of trying to fix this, even Amazon has given up. But not all companies have. So when AI meets diversity policy, what you get is … at least NOT consistent.

See:  Canada’s financial upstarts are lining up behind open banking, but bigger players may need convincing

Inadequate data sets

Deducing mood, psychological state, sexual orientation, intelligence, likelihood of paedophilia or terrorism through “analyzing” facial expression keeps being shown to be inaccurate, outdated, biased, and based on inaccurate datasets. This is not benevolence.

Training AI to seek “criminal face” using data consisting of prisoners’ faces is not representative of crime, but rather, represents which criminals have been caught, jailed, and photographed. A high percentage of criminals are never caught or punished, so the dataset cannot adequately represent crime itself. We are back in the land of phrenology…or worse.

We all know there are some scientific research programs best not pursued—and this might be one of them.

Illegality

Hiring AI used by fast food companies has been shown by Cathy O’Neill to screen out those with any hint of history of mental illness – a move specifically prohibited by the Americans with Disabilities Act. But attempts to investigate this so far have been stalled by claims that the AI is a trade secret and cannot be disclosed. One law for humans – another for machines. This isn’t integrity in action.

Socially deaf definitions of success

Attempts to use AI to allocate school places more fairly in Boston backfired completely when it turned out that nobody programming the AI had the faintest idea – let alone experience – of the way that poor families live, the timetables that working 3 jobs imposes on them and their children. Not only were results worse – they came wrapped in insult. This isn’t benevolent and it was, frankly, incompetent.

These are real cases. There are more. Each one might be nit-picked apart but the key issue is this:

AI oversteps a fundamental boundary between objective analysis and moral judgment.

When such moral judgments are made, people deserve a chance to understand and to validate or to contest them. Claims of trade secrecy specifically militate against this.  Ethical issues are treated as legal and policy issues – a way of sidelining them that is completely synonymous with the way that hierarchies and bureaucracies facilitate, indeed drive, wilful blindness in organizations.

See:  [Report] A New North Star: Canadian Competitiveness in an Intangibles Economy

AI simply amplifies both the risk and the lack of accountability to an unimaginable scale. You could say it delivers the status quo PLUS. So AI has the capacity to increase and sustain marginalization, corporate malfeasance and inequality.

All of the companies involved in developing it know this. That’s why there’s a whole roster of organizations all trying to figure out how to make AI the commercial goldrush it promises to be – while also hoping to silence fears that anything could possibly go wrong. But there are 2 difficulties with their approach:

  • Almost all of these organizations are set up, run and incorporate very large institutional interests. These are not the critics of the status quo but its beneficiaries. They start from a position that is inherently unrepresentative
    While these talking shops assuage nervous politicians, business as usual continues with a language of inevitability: AI is coming, AI is here, you have no choice but to stand back and take it. It’s too difficult for you bumpkins to understand – so just leave it to us. Or, to quote the CEO of Axon (the company that conveniently changed its name from Taser) speaking in defence of facial recognition cameras:

“It would be both naive and counterproductive to say law enforcement shouldn’t have these new technologies. They’re going to, and I think they’re going to need them. We can’t have police in the 2020s policing with technologies from the 1990s”[1]

“‘Sit down. Shut up. When I want something from you, I’ll ask’, is the tenor of so-called public consultation”

This is the language of propaganda: telling people that these new technologies are inevitable- when they aren’t – and that they’re unequivocally productive – when they aren’t – and therefore there is no need, no POINT in asking questions. ‘Sit down. Shut up. When I want something from you, I’ll ask’ is the tenor of so-called public consultation.

Continue to the full article --> here


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability” The National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

Latest news - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”FF Logo 400 v3 - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”community social impact - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”
FFCON23 Fintech Funding Deal Flow - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”

Share for a Chance to Win FREE #FFCON23 Virtual Event Tickets!!


As a part of the lead-up to this exciting event, NCFA will be holding a social media contest for the chance to win FREE tickets to attend. In order to be entered to win, all you’ll need to do is share any of our event posts or create one of your own through your Facebook, Twitter, Instagram or LinkedIn personal or company page, tag @NCFACanada, and use #FFCON23. Winners will be contacted prior to the event. We look forward to seeing you there!

FFCON23 Share on Social for Chance to Win Free Tickets  - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”

Support NCFA by Following us on Twitter!







NCFA Sign up for our newsletter - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”




Reuters | March 22, 2023 The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has threatened to sue Coinbase Global Inc over some of the crypto exchange's products, turning up the heat on the largely unregulated sector. The potential enforcement actions would be tied to aspects of Coinbase's spot market as well as its Earn, Prime and Wallet products, the company said. Shares of Coinbase dropped nearly 13% to $67.33 in extended trading after the company said on Wednesday that the regulator had issued it a Wells notice - a formal declaration that SEC staff intend to recommend an enforcement action. Coinbase said its services continued to operate as usual after the notice was issued. See:  Coinbase Begins ‘Wallet as a Service’ Enabling Companies to Integrate Into Their Own Apps A Wells notice does not always result in charges or signal that the recipient has violated any law.  A Wells notice is typically one of the final steps before the SEC formally issues charges. It generally lays out the framework of the regulatory argument and offers the potentially accused an opportunity to rebut the SEC’s claims. Coinbase Chief Legal Officer Paul Grewal said in a blog post: Although we don’t take this ...
Read More
Wells notice coinbase - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”
CoinDesk | Nikhilesh De, Oliver Knight | March 22, 2023 Sushi DAO and Head Chef Jared Grey were served with a subpoena by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, the decentralized autonomous organization revealed Tuesday. Grey proposed creating a "Sushi DAO Legal Defense Fund" in a forum post, saying it would "cover legal costs for core contributors." The proposal recommends making $3 million in tether (USDT) available for core contributors, with another $1 million worth of USDT available in case the initial $3 million are used up. The sushi token dropped 5.5% on the news. One of the initial comments on the forum post asked how the DAO known as Sushi was subpoenaed, with the user saying they did not receive it despite being a member of the DAO. "We’re cooperating with the SEC. We do not intend to comment publicly on ongoing investigations or other legal matters," the forum post said. Continue to the full article --> here The National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to ...
Read More
Sushi - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”
March 22, 2023 Regarding legal matters: it's always better to be safe than sorry. While there are many situations where a person may try to navigate legal issues on their own - there are instances wherein hiring a lawyer is an absolute must. Here are the top six situations when hiring a lawyer is essential. Criminal Charges If you are facing criminal charges, hiring a lawyer right away is essential. An attorney can help protect your rights, build a strong defense, and negotiate with prosecutors. When choosing a lawyer, it's critical to find someone with experience in your case's specific area of law. You'll also want to ensure that the lawyer has a good track record and a reputation for being a strong advocate for their clients. The seasoned legal practitioners behind https://colbylegal.com/ recommend that you opt for a lawyer who is responsive and attentive to your needs, as well as someone who will keep you informed throughout the legal process. This way, you can make better decisions about your case and feel confident that you're getting the best representation. Personal Injury Claims Hiring a personal injury lawyer is necessary if you sustained injuries due to an accident caused by ...
Read More
Pixabay advogadoaguilar lawyer at work - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”
Exploding Topics | Josh Howarth | Jan 20, 2023 The fintech space is making fast strides across many financial sectors, including consumer and B2B.  Fintech investment and consumer adoption are clearly on the rise. But to what extent? And where is this industry headed?  This list has you covered with a wide range of key, up-to-date financial technology (fintech) statistics. Fintech Industry Size: The fintech industry is worth approximately $180 billion (Deloitte) Global fintech industry revenue has nearly doubled since 2017 (Deloitte) There are currently over 26,000 fintech startups worldwide. This figure has grown dramatically over the past few years (up from only around 12,000 fintech startups in 2019). See:  KPMG: Canadian Fintech Investment Drops in 2022, Mentality Shift to ‘Sensible’ Growth Investment: Fintech industry investment has increased 3.5x since 2015 (KPMG) In 2012, investment in fintech totaled $4 billion.  By the end of 2021, fintech investment reached $210 billion. Venture capital distributions by sector funding: #1 Capital markets $8.07 billion #2 Payments $6.03 billion #3 Wealth management $5.43 billion #4 Digital lending $3.97 billion #5 SMB $3.36 billion #6 Banking $3.27 billion #7 Real estate $2.42 billion #8 Insurance $2.30 billion Adoption: 90% of Chinese citizens use fintech banking, ...
Read More
VC funding by fintech sector - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”
March 21, 2023 If you don't plan, you're planning to fail, as the old business adage goes. It's a cliché, but those who are really committed to their achievement, especially traders, should treat those words as if they were carved in stone. If you ask every successful trader, the answer will likely be the same: you must strictly adhere to a predetermined strategy, or you will be doomed to failure. You're in the minority if you already have a detailed trading or investment strategy that will help your portfolio, and congratulations on that. Creating a viable strategy or technique for trading the financial markets is a lengthy process that requires much study and investigation. While there are no guarantees, you have removed a substantial obstacle. For those of you who haven’t done it yet, here is a comprehensive guide on how to do so in order to get solid results and improve your portfolio. Have a Clear Understand of the Market A solid understanding of the market you are going to trade on is vital for establishing a smart trading strategy. Being well-versed in the field of trading will equip you to comfortably deal with the abundance of data present ...
Read More
Pixabay 3844328 stock trading - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”
CFPB | Mar 15, 2023 The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) issued a request for information on “data brokers,” “an umbrella term to describe firms that collect, aggregate, sell, resell, license, or otherwise share consumers’ personal information with other parties. See:  Davos: Cooperation in a Fragmented World: In Data We Trust The CFPB is looking to better understand the “scope and breadth of data brokers’ business practices and the impact of those practices on the marketplace and peoples’ daily lives,” especially in relation to credit reporting and the requirements and intentions of the Fair Credit Reporting Act. Continue to view the announcement --> here Download the 13 page PDF RIF --> here The National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech ...
Read More
Pixabay TheHilaryClark on mobile - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”
Reuters | Stefania Spezzati, Oliver Hirt and John O'Donnell | Mar 19, 2023 Move follows Swiss rescue of Credit Suisse and signals depth of concern over the global financial system Some of the world’s largest central banks came together on Sunday to stop a banking crisis from spreading as Swiss authorities persuaded UBS Group AG to buy rival Credit Suisse Group AG in a historic deal. UBS will pay 3 billion Swiss francs (US$3.23 billion) for 167-year-old Credit Suisse and assume up to US$5.4 billion in losses in a deal backed by a massive Swiss guarantee and expected to close by the end of 2023. Soon after the announcement late on March 19, the U.S. Federal Reserve, the Bank of Canada, European Central Bank and other major central banks came out with statements to reassure markets that have been walloped by a banking crisis that started with the collapse of two regional U.S. banks earlier this month.  The Fed said it had joined with central banks in Canada, England, Japan, the EU and Switzerland in a coordinated action to enhance market liquidity. The banks said they would start offering daily loans in dollars to their banks to avert stress in ...
Read More
Unsplash John McArthur global currencies - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”
Stripe | March 15, 2023 Stripe, a financial infrastructure platform for businesses, today announced OpenAI has chosen Stripe to power payments as it moves to commercialize its groundbreaking ChatGPT and DALL·E generative AI technologies. Powering OpenAI with Stripe:  OpenAI is working with Stripe to commercialize its generative AI technology. Using Stripe’s suite of products, OpenAI was able to launch a global payments system for multiple product lines in a matter of weeks. See:  Human vs Machine’s Tug-of-War: Stockmarket Automation Lessons GPT-3: Stripe has long used artificial intelligence to enhance its products and experiences for users, including to help users manage fraud and increase conversion rates. Last year, Stripe worked with Microsoft’s Azure OpenAI team to implement GPT-3 for Stripe Support, which is helping agents identify quicker resolution paths for the many users they interact with each week. Seventy-five percent of the leading generative AI companies have signed up with Stripe to go to market quickly, scale with compliance in mind, and bring their products to many more users worldwide. They include OpenAI, Runway, Diagram, and Moonbeam. GPT-4: After joining the GPT-4 beta in January, Stripe identified a range of ways to use the technology to streamline operations and help users ...
Read More
OpenAI and Stripe - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”
March 20, 2023 Cloud-based solutions utilize live data analysis to equip your HR managers with vital resources that can enhance staff involvement. These solutions also enable your HR team to create personalized development plans for each employee, empowering them to take ownership of their career paths and achieve their professional goals. Incorporating the following cloud-based solutions in your HR department can significantly improve employee satisfaction and boost company performance. This article will examine 5 cloud-based solutions to help HR leverage employee engagement: 1. Video conferencing tools Video conferencing tools are cloud-based solutions that have become increasingly popular as organizations look for ways to improve and maintain employee engagement and collaboration in remote work environments. These tools effectively allow your HR department to connect with employees regardless of location, enabling better communication, engagement and teamwork. They also allow the HR team to hold meetings, conduct interviews, and even organize virtual events, such as team-building activities, without being in the same physical location. These tools can enable you to easily communicate updates on company policies and procedures, discuss career development opportunities, and offer feedback on employee performance. 2. Digital signage software Cloud-based digital signage involves utilizing a digital signage system hosted on ...
Read More
Unsplash Celpax employee engagement - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”
March 19, 2023 If you were to visit any legitimate online or land-based casino, you would notice that they strongly recommend responsible gambling. What this means is that you need to be very careful with your bankroll management. This is the best way to remain in control, avoid unnecessary frustration, and prevent yourself from making reckless decisions. Getting too emotional can turn this whole entertaining experience into a problem. So, if you are new to this hobby make sure to stick around, and read about some bankroll management tips. These will help you minimize your losses, and have a more enjoyable gaming experience by extension. Use Casino Bonuses and Promotions First off, playing online actually gives you a lot of flexibility for managing expenses. If you live in places like Canada there are lots of online casinos available and they have incredibly generous bonuses. You should go over the list of the best online casinos for Canadians and pick a few operators that you like. Right off the bet, you will see you can get lots of free spins for just a small and negligible deposit. Bear in mind though that some of these bonuses do have wagering requirements, so ...
Read More
Unsplash Kelly Sikkema calculator on phone - Technology, Legitimacy & Social Justice: Fighting “the propaganda of inevitability”

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

eleven − 7 =