Decentralized Venture Ecosystem

UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status “Clearly Not Sustainable”

Squire Patton Boggs LLP | Katherine Wakeham and Chris Webber | Oct 30, 2018

UK considering crypto regulations - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"Last month, the House of Commons Treasury Committee published its report on crypto-assets. The report expresses serious concerns about the risks of consumer harm and financial crime and calls for regulation “as a matter of urgency“.

Crypto-assets?

It is striking that the Committee did not consider it appropriate to refer to "crypto-currencies" in the current landscape. They felt that these assets were failing to perform key functions of a currency, because:

  • The price volatility of such assets meant they were not a good store of value. The Bank of England gave evidence that Bitcoin is 10x more volatile than sterling against the US dollar. Other crypto-assets showed even greater fluctuations.
  • There was insufficient market liquidity and capacity for these assets to act as a medium of exchange. The Committee noted evidence that the blockchains for some crypto-assets were struggling to handle current payment volumes, leading to higher transaction fees and/or delays in executing transactions. The transaction fees were exacerbated by the higher energy costs of blockchain's decentralised system.
  • There were no crypto-assets being routinely or widely used as a unit of account. Even Bitcoin is not widely accepted.

The term "crypto-assets" was preferred.

See:  SEC Launches Fintech Hub To Engage With Cryptocurrency Startups And More

The Committee's conclusions

The Committee acknowledged some of the advantages and opportunities of crypto-asset and distributed ledger technology. But it found there were interlinking limitations. In particular:

  • The same reasons crypto-assets could not be termed 'cryptocurrencies' also put a limit on the extent to which they were capable of replacing traditional payments systems.
  • The price volatility made crypto-assets "especially risky, particularly for inexperienced retail investors".
  • The Committee looked at the hacking of exchanges, noting a lack of compensation scheme or arrangements put in place by the exchanges themselves. The Committee considered that "The risk of hacking associated with crypto-assets may not be something investors in conventional assets have experience of... they may not be well placed to judge this risk."
  • the Report notes that Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs) have "exposed a regulatory loophole that is being exploited to the detriment of ordinary investors." Although ICOs may be structured to fall outside the existing regulation, investors were clearly expecting financial returns in a similar manner to regulated investments.
  • The Committee noted suspicions that crypto-exchanges are being used to facilitate money laundering and terrorist financing, since they enable anonymous transacting. The Report acknowledged conflicting views on how significant this criminal use is. The Fifth Anti-Money Laundering Directive will bring crypto-exchanges within the money laundering regulations by 10 January 2020, but the Committee urges the UK Government to implement the regulations more promptly.

Some limitations identified by the Committee are inherent. Others could be reduced and/or eliminated by effective regulation. Presently, the FCA has no powers to regulate crypto-assets themselves and only limited scope to regulate ICOs. This limits the FCA to issuing warnings drawing attention to the risks investors in these products face. The Report considered such warnings "a feeble corrective to advertisements...that only emphasise the upside opportunities of crypto-asset investing". This led the Committee to conclude that:

"Given the scale and variety of consumer detriment, the potential role of crypto-assets in money laundering and the inadequacy of self-regulation, the Committee strongly believes that regulation should be introduced. At a minimum regulation should address consumer protection and money laundering."

See:  Exploring cryptoasset regulation

What might regulation look like?

There is currently a level of self-regulation within the industry, but the Committee considered this insufficient. The Committee's recommended that in the first instance "The Regulated Activities Order should be updated to bring ICOs within the FCA's perimeter… and bring investor protections into line with those in the United States", where the Securities and Exchange Commission generally treats utility token issues as within existing securities laws. The Committee considered that this:

"...would be the quickest method of providing the FCA with the necessary legal powers to execute its duties of protecting consumers and maintaining market integrity. Designing a new framework of regulation would inevitably take much longer and given the growing risks surrounding crypto-assets and subsequent consumer detriment, the introduction of regulation should be treated as a matter of urgency."

The Committee suggested that regulation should include, at least, issuing ICOs and providing crypto exchange services.

The Committee also considered that, whilst there didn't appear to be a significant risk to market stability caused by crypto-assets, the Bank of England and FCA should continue to monitor this risk.

Continue to the full article --> here


NCFA Jan 2018 resize - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable" The National Crowdfunding & Fintech Association (NCFA Canada) is a financial innovation ecosystem that provides education, market intelligence, industry stewardship, networking and funding opportunities and services to thousands of community members and works closely with industry, government, partners and affiliates to create a vibrant and innovative fintech and funding industry in Canada. Decentralized and distributed, NCFA is engaged with global stakeholders and helps incubate projects and investment in fintech, alternative finance, crowdfunding, peer-to-peer finance, payments, digital assets and tokens, blockchain, cryptocurrency, regtech, and insurtech sectors. Join Canada's Fintech & Funding Community today FREE! Or become a contributing member and get perks. For more information, please visit: www.ncfacanada.org

Latest news - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"FF Logo 400 v3 - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"community social impact - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"

Support NCFA by Following us on Twitter!






NCFA Sign up for our newsletter - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"



Not to be missed! Registration NOW OPEN!

Help us kickoff the Summer in style


NCFA Summer Kickoff Jun 9 2022 Flyer 800 - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"




The Defiant | Aleksandar Gilbert | May 16, 2022 Stablecoins haven’t looked so stable recently. The United Kingdom doesn’t seem to be too worried Despite the recent collapse of Terra’s UST stablecoin, the U.K. government will move forward with proposed regulations that would facilitate stablecoins’ use  “as a recognised form of payment,” according to a report from The Telegraph. A spokesman for Her Majesty’s Treasury told the U.K.-based newspaper said: Legislation to regulate stablecoins, where used as a means of payment, will be part of the Financial Services and Markets Bill which was announced in the Queen’s Speech. Apr 5:  UK government: Sets sights on being a global hub for cryptoasset technology with flexible future regulation The UK government said in a report issued last month after more than 12 months of study: [Fiat-backed stablecoins] have the capacity to potentially become a widespread means of payment.  An amended e-money framework can deliver a consistent framework to regulate stablecoin issuance and the provision of wallets and custody services. ‘Global Hub For Crypto Assets’ Rishi Sunak, the Chancellor of the Exchequer said: We want to see the businesses of tomorrow – and the jobs they create – here in the UK,” he continued, and ...
Read More
UK global cryptoasset hub - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"
Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance | May 17, 2022 New mining map data, spanning the period from September 2021 to January 2022, included shows that the US has remained at the forefront of Bitcoin mining and extended its leading position (37.84%) amidst the global hashrate recovery. Following a sudden uptick in covert mining operations after the June 2021 government-mandated ban on Bitcoin mining, China has re-emerged as a major mining hub (21.11%). Kazakhstan (13.22%), Canada (6.48%), and Russia (4.66%) have been relegated to more distant places. See:  Bitcoin Mining Council Protest ‘Misleading’ Letter Sent to EPA Bitcoin mining is worse for the environment since China banned it Bitcoin Electricity Consumption Index (CBECI): China’s crackdown puts US in pole position and Canada in 4th When we released the last update of the Cambridge Bitcoin Electricity Consumption Index (CBECI), mining map in October 2021 (covering data up to the end of August 2021), the Bitcoin network was grappling with the consequences of the Chinese ban on domestic mining activities. The government crackdown immediately resulted in a harsh decline of the total hashrate – the network’s aggregate computing power – which bottomed at 57.47 Exahashes per second (EH/s) on 27 June 2021. A ...
Read More
CCAF Bitcoin mining map - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"
a16z crypto | Daren Matsuoka, Eddy Lazzarin, Chris Dixon, and Robert Hackett | May 17, 2022 This report is the first of what will be an annual overview of trends in the crypto industry, shared through the a16z crypto vantage point of both tracking data and across the countless entrepreneurs and builders we meet. It’s for anyone who seeks to understand the evolution of the internet, and where we are on the journey towards a decentralized, community-owned-and-operated alternative to the centralized tech platforms of web2 – especially as it touches creators and other builders. 5 Key Takeaways 1. We’re in the middle of the fourth ‘price-innovation’ cycle Although crypto can be volatile and its cycles seem chaotic, there is an underlying logic at work, as Chris and Eddy first pointed out in 2020. (See slides 9 through 12 in the deck.) Whereas prices are often a lagging indicator of performance in some industries, in crypto they are a leading indicator. Prices are a hook. The numbers drive interest, which drives ideas and activity, which in turn drives innovation. We call this feedback loop “the price-innovation cycle”, and it has been the engine that has propelled the industry through multiple distinct ...
Read More
Total AUM by bank including defi - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"
The Verge | Mitchell Clark  | May 16, 2022 In the wake of the sudden collapse of TerraUSD, several other stablecoins’ values (whose values are supposedly pegged to the dollar) have started facing issues. Deus Finance’s DEI coin is currently trading at around 66 cents and has been fluctuating since Sunday, reaching a low of around 52 cents early Monday morning. Unlike other major stablecoins like USD Coin and Tether, which (allegedly) have actual dollars or assets backing them, DEI’s values are controlled by algorithms making trades. It’s not that there’s no collateral — as CoinTelegraph points out, there’s a DEUS token that you can use to get new DEI tokens and that you can receive if you redeemed DEI. See:  Ottawa to review Crypto, Stablecoins and CBDCs; Budget promises more financial cops The Terra coin lost its peg to the dollar, eventually leading to massive inflation in the accompanying Luna coin. Eventually, the Terra blockchain was frozen, and many major exchanges delisted it from sale. The destabilization of DEI and other coins has also opened up a new attack on a decentralized finance protocol called Scream, which lets users borrow cryptocurrencies by posting other ones as collateral. According to ...
Read More
depegged coins - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"
CoinDesk | Sam Kessler, Shaurya Malwa | May 16, 2022 The announcement comes after criticism of the Luna Foundation Guard's "lack of transparency." The Luna Foundation Guard (LFG), official stewards of Terra’s bitcoin (BTC) reserves, released a statement on Monday documenting how it disbursed millions of dollars' worth of crypto in its failed attempt to maintain the peg of stablecoin terraUSD (UST). In the statement, LFG notes that it has almost entirely depleted its BTC reserves from around 80,000 bitcoins to 313. The remaining assets, which mostly comprise the crashed UST and LUNA tokens, will apparently be used to compensate investors. In one of the most calamitous events in crypto memory, the $40 billion Terra ecosystem collapsed last week when the UST stablecoin, which is supposed to be worth $1, dropped to below 20 cents. The LUNA token, which is designed to serve as a sort of shock absorber for UST’s “algorithmic” dollar-pegging mechanism, crashed from $80 to below 2 cents. See:  Terra is transitioning from a dollar-pegged stablecoin to a bitcoin-backed stablecoin In a tweet on Monday, LFG said it sold off most of the BTC in its reserves for UST as Terra’s ecosystem was beginning to collapse early ...
Read More
moon over water - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"
Guest Post | May 16, 2022 Education is a rapidly evolving sector. A few decades ago, traditional education was the only acceptable model. We had blackboards, wooden desks, bulky textbooks, and detention for naughty students. Fast forward to the 21st century, and most of the symbols of traditional education have now been replaced by technology. Thanks to the infusion of technology into education, we now have Brighterly.com and other online learning platforms. But that’s not where it ends. Technology has equally birthed a new genre of education known as “edutainment.” But what exactly is edutainment? And how is it transforming traditional education? Let’s take a quick look, shall we? What Is Edutainment? As the name implies, edutainment is a combination of education and entertainment. It was first used in 1954 by Walt Disney to describe the new True Life Adventure series. Basically, it means infusing education with entertainment to make learning an enjoyable experience for students. With the COVID-19 pandemic and the consequent disruption to education, students have been finding it harder to learn. However, as we all teach and learn post-pandemic, it’s time to infuse fun and joy into learning to boost students’ motivation and participation. See:  The digital ...
Read More
Eductainment - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"
TechCrunch | Jacquelyn Melinek | May 10, 2022 Stablecoins have been a hot topic both on and off Capitol Hill. Earlier today, U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen pushed for regulation during an annual testimony in front of the Senate Banking Committee, at a time where Terra’s algorithmic stablecoin UST struggles to retain its peg. US Treasury Secretary, Janet Yellen, said: New products and technology may present opportunities to promote innovation and increase efficiencies. However, digital assets may present risks to the financial system and increased and coordinated regulatory attention is necessary. A stablecoin known as TerraUSD experienced a run and declined in value, [which] illustrates that this is a rapidly growing product and there are rapidly growing risks.  It would be highly appropriate for stablecoin regulation to occur by the end of 2022 because there are “many risks associated with cryptocurrencies.” See:  Terra Networks’ Stablecoin Loses Dollar Peg (again) Dives 45% (Update: to near zero) Adding More Pressure on Bitcoin Stablecoins by definition are supposed to be stable and hold their value through a 1:1 ratio that is fixed to an external peg like the U.S. dollar or it can be tied to other assets like UST, which is backed ...
Read More
Janet Yellen US Treasury secretary - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"
London Loves Business | Apr 27, 2022 Outfund are changing the way online businesses raise funds, today announces the close of a £115M Series A round of equity capital and debt amount. The funding round was led by Force Over Mass, PostFinance, 1818 Venture Capital and Tribe Capital, and will support Outfund’s rapid global growth as it provides a faster, fairer and more affordable way for SMEs to raise growth capital across the globe.  With this new investment, Outfund is pledging to invest more than £500m of lending to over 5,000 businesses in the next 12 months, and will increase its lending limit to £10m per company. See:  Corl raises $20 Million USD to expand Revenue-Based Financing in North America Outfund can deploy between £10,000 and £10million of funding, and is available to businesses that take online payments, have a minimum of £10,000 monthly turnover, and have been trading for at least six months.  Only simple checks are required to access capital and there is no need for companies to provide business plans or go through prolonged risk assessments. Businesses simply connect their revenue accounts and, with access to this data, Outfund will build a funding offer and deploy the same ...
Read More
revenue based financing - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"
IMF | LinkedIn John Ho | May 11, 2022 The IMF has today published a report on how crypto assets might be used to circumvent capital flow management measures, undermining the stability of domestic economies and the global system Highlights: Capital flows can bring substantial benefits for countries but also carry risks. Capital flow management measures (CFMs) can be part of the broader policy toolkit to help countries reap the benefits of capital flows while managing the associated risks. Implementation of CFMs typically requires that financial intermediaries verify the nature of transactions & the identities of transacting parties, but it is facing the rising challenge of crypto assets. See:  IMF asks Financial Stability Board to develop a global framework for standards for regulation of crypto assets Crypto assets have become a significant instrument for payments and speculative investments in some countries, driven by a host of macroeconomic, institutional, & demographic factors. Crypto assets can be traded pseudonymously and held without identification of the residency of the asset holder. Many crypto service providers operate across borders, making supervision & enforcement by national authorities more difficult. The challenges posed by the attributes of crypto assets are compounded by gaps in the legal & regulatory ...
Read More
IMF fintech notes crypto assets cash flow management - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"
PYMNTS | Mar 31, 2022 The European Union has passed several laws aimed at providing digital identity protection, among them the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), which went into effect in 2018. Among the biggest violators of these protocols? American websites. According to one study, 67% of the top 1,000 websites in the United States were in violation of the GDPR. The violations at work here vary, with 43% of websites not offering users the ability to opt out of selling data, 55% failing to notify users of cookies when they visit the site for the first time, and 32% of sites containing ad trackers. See:  How Verifiable Digital Identity Will Protect Your Post-Pandemic Privacy The study pointed out that while GDPR exclusively concerns Europe, websites originating in the U.S. still sell goods and services to EU customers.  Fines for violations of the GDPR range from $80,000 to $120,000. To help smaller app developers make sure they’re complying with the GDPR — and thus avoiding penalties they may not be able to afford — Google has launched a new platform called Checks that leverages artificial intelligence (AI) to scan code bases and evaluate them for privacy and other areas in ...
Read More
GDPR - UK: A Step Towards UK Crypto-Asset Regulation? Treasury Committee Report Finds Current Status "Clearly Not Sustainable"

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *